Skip to content
Gigantum.net
Politics

Why lame-duck Republicans are blocking Trump’s judicial picks

Watch The Gavel Live: Hill Insider members can join us live today at 3 p.m. EST as we discuss the vibes at the Federalist Society’s convention, the biggest gathering of the year for the conservative legal movement, in the wake of Democrats’ midterm sweep. Senate Republicans are hitting some surprising hurdles as they race to confirm as…

· 2,579 words· updated November 18, 2026 at 08:32 AM
FILE – The Supreme Court is seen, June 30, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana, File)
FILE – The Supreme Court is seen, June 30, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana, File)

Watch The Gavel Live: Hill Insider members can join us live today at 3 p.m. EST as we discuss the vibes at the Federalist Society’s convention, the biggest gathering of the year for the conservative legal movement, in the wake of Democrats’ midterm sweep.

Senate Republicans are hitting some surprising hurdles as they race to confirm as many of President Trump’s judicial picks as possible in the 46 days they have before Democrats take control of Congress.

Arkansas’s senators successfully blocked one of Trump’s circuit court nominees.

Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) doesn’t seem to care for the president nominating a Justice Department official to a judgeship in his state.

And Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) is signaling there will be a battle to confirm an Oklahoma nominee.

The Senate Judiciary Committee under Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) is moving quickly despite the problems.

Grassley scheduled back-to-back hearings this week in an effort to advance nominees, a “mad scramble” that Democrats argue violates longstanding norms.

“Remember this day when a future Democratic chair moves judicial nominees through the committee with one week for you to review their background and qualifications for a lifetime appointment,” Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Illinois), the committee’s ranking member, warned his Republican colleagues on Tuesday.

Many of the battles are being waged by lame-duck Republican senators whose relationships with Trump have frayed.

Cornyn has become a thorn in Trump’s side in his final months as a senator, showing an increased willingness to use his leverage to hold up legislation and appointments he opposes. It’s made some GOP observers unhappy.

“Politics, more often than it should be, is high school,” Mike Fragoso , who previously advised Sen. Mitch McConnell’ s (R-Ky.) and Grassley, wrote on social media .

“Does it have to be? That’s the question left to individual politicians, like John Cornyn, who—in the end—are accountable only for themselves and their own choices,” Fragoso continued.

Cornyn, who will exit the Senate at the end of this Congress, has refused to submit a blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser , the head of the DOJ’s Office of Legal Counsel, effectively blocking his confirmation hearing for a seat on the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of Texas.

Refresh: The “blue slip” process is a tradition in which the Senate Judiciary Committee chairman asks home-state senators to assess the nomination of a U.S. district court nominee. If the form is withheld or returned with objections, the nomination typically does not move forward.

A Cornyn aide tells The Gavel he has instead been pushing the White House for months to recommend Steve Fahey , a former federal prosecutor, for the vacancy.

“The purpose of advice and consent is to have a consultation, and the White House has completely ignored that,” Cornyn told reporters in the Capitol on Monday. “And I don’t want the seat to go vacant, so we’ve recommended somebody who can be confirmed. But I’m not willing to let the White House ignore the Senate’s constitutional role.”

In Arkansas, Republican Sens. Tom Cotton and John Boozman successfully tanked Trump’s nominee to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8 th Circuit, Lee Rudofsky , to the chagrin of some conservatives.

Their pressure led to Trump to swap out Rudofsky for the duo’s pick, Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Cody Hiland.

It was a nod that Hiland expected to get — only months earlier. He told a room full of law students at the University of Arkansas in August that he had already gone through the vetting process for the 8 th Circuit job when the White House changed course and offered him a district court seat instead.

He turned it down, recounting the surprised reaction he received from White House counsel on the other end of the phone call.

“He said, ‘So you want me to go back into the Oval Office and tell the President of the United States that you’re rejecting an opportunity to be appointed to the federal bench, and I said, ‘Yes, that’s exactly what I want you to tell the president of the United States,'” Hiland recalled .

A battle is also emerging in Oklahoma over Trump’s selection of Zach West and Trevor Pemberton to federal judgeships in the state.

Both nominations were on the Judiciary Committee’s agenda Tuesday, but their names were skipped over without explanation. Like the Arkansas standoff, some conservative lawyers have their eyes laser-focused on the clock.

“I have it on very good authority that Oklahomans will either have two new judges soon or they will have zero new judges for at least two years,” Rob Luther , who previously worked in the White House counsel’s office under Trump, wrote on social media two days before the hearing.

Luther’s assessment followed an earlier Reuters report that indicated Sen. Alan Armstrong (R-Okla.) had pulled back his support for West after previously returning a blue slip. That position has Tillis’ backing, according to the outlet, which complicates the confirmation math as Republicans can afford only one defection on party-line votes.

It’s not over yet. Kevin Hern , who won the election in November to permanently fill the Senate seat currently held by Armstrong, is set to be sworn in at the end of the month. He told Bloomberg he’ll support Trump’s pick, and Tillis signaled he may also be willing to drop his opposition.

“Frankly, it’s an unforced error by the White House just not to consult more effectively with Senator Armstrong,” Tillis reportedly said. “I think he’ll get done, but they’re running it down to the wire.”

Welcome to The Gavel, The Hill’s weekly newsletter unpacking the intersection of courts & politics from Zach Schonfeld and Sophie Brams. Email us tips at zschonfeld@thehill.com and sbrams@thehill.com . You can also reach out to us on X (@ZachASchonfeld and @sophiebrams) or Signal (zachschonfeld.48 and sbrams.32).

Lucas targets top admin officials: Virginia Senate President Pro Tem L. Louise Lucas (D) is asking a federal judge to sanction Attorney General Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel for “extrajudicial statements” made during a public press conference in October announcing charges related to an alleged marijuana conspiracy scheme.

Trump’s East Potomac plans hit snag : East Potomac Park remains open to the public after U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes blocked the Trump administration from closing it for at least two weeks, a setback for Trump in his bid to redevelop the golf courses into a single championship-level facility capable of hosting major professional tournaments.

Dems, DOJ trade threats ahead of oversight blitz: Aaron Reitz, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas, is firing warning shots at incoming House Oversight and Government Reform Committee Chair Robert Garcia (D-Calif.) and other senators as Democrats prepare to launch an investigative blitz into the Trump administration’s activities when they return to power.

Conservative justices in FedSoc spotlight : Justices Amy Coney Barrett, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh reflected on the nation’s 250 th anniversary in a series of pre-taped interviews for the Federalist Society’s annual National Lawyers Conference last week. Justice Samuel Alito delivered a surprise speech during the Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner, warning that the Supreme Court was “vulnerable” to Congress and the executive branch.

Clancy gets retrial date: Lindsey Clancy will go back on trial in early March for the alleged murders of her three young children in 2023, a Massachusetts judge has decided. The state’s first attempt to prosecute Clancy ended in a mistrial after jurors were unable to reach a unanimous verdict on whether she should be held criminally liable for the deaths.

Federalist Society convention attendees were invited to sit down for lunch with conservative federal judges and learn about their hobbies. We took notes. Here are some of our favorites (join us on the live show for the full listing)

Emil Bove , 3 rd Circuit: “Off-Grid Living”

James Ho , 5 th Circuit: “You’ve Got to Have Hobbies”

Rebecca Taibleson , 7 th Circuit: “True Crime Media”

Patrick Bumatay , 9 th Circuit: “Horror Movies”

“The Best Justice System in the World,” a new documentary by University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign law professor Suja Thomas that explores the flaws of the U.S. justice system, premiered at the DOC NYC Film Festival over the weekend. Watch the trailer .

Harvard Law School has postponed the remaining qualifying and semifinal rounds of its prestigious Ames Moot Court Competition until next spring due to an ongoing strike by the Harvard Graduate Students Union-United Auto Workers. Read more from The Harvard Law Record.

A wrinkle in the Supreme Court battle over AR-15s

A major gun battle is headed to the justices next month. Or is it?

Weeks ahead of oral arguments on whether states can ban AR-15s and semiautomatic rifles, one of the plaintiffs is dropping out of the case.

Cutberto Viramontes provided no explanation for his decision, which throws a potential wrinkle into the blockbuster Second Amendment battle set to impact bans in nearly a dozen blue states.

Everyone had agreed Viramontes had legal standing to bring the challenge. He wanted to buy an AR-15, and Cook County, Ill. — which includes Chicago — prevents him from doing so.

The other individual suing alongside him, Christopher Khaya , wants to own an IMI Galil semiautomatic rifle.

And that’s relevant, the county says, because the Supreme Court took up the case only to decide if the Second Amendment protects “AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles.” Cook County says Khaya’s desired firearm is more like an AK-47, not an AR-15, so he isn’t a suitable challenger.

“Should petitioners disavow their prior statement and argue that the IMI Galil weapon is ‘similar’ to an AR-15, the record would not support that about-face. There are no record facts concerning whether the IMI Galil weapon operates similarly to an AR-15,” Cook County wrote to the justices .

The county wants the Supreme Court to throw out the lawsuit.

The challengers’ lawyers say the Supreme Court should proceed as normal, arguing that Khaya and the gun rights groups suing, the Firearms Policy Coalition and the Second Amendment Foundation, all have standing.

“Indeed, until now, the County’s litigation position has been that the rifles are interchangeable,” they wrote in court filings .

The Supreme Court has yet to resolve the dispute as the oral arguments approach.

Whichever way it shakes out, don’t expect the AR-15 battle to completely fizzle out at the Supreme Court.

Alongside the Chicago-area lawsuit, they’ve taken up a challenge to a similar law in Connecticut. No one has suggested a standing problem there.

Cases the Supreme Court is taking up — or passing on — this term.

The Supreme Court turned away dozens of cases at its final meeting of the November session, but it took up two new ones. We highlighted both in last week’s edition as ones to keep an eye on:

In Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, the justices will decide if President Trump’s asylum ban is legal.

On Inauguration Day, Trump declared an invasion at the southern border to effectively shut down asylum applications. Lower courts ruled it exceeded his authority, though they have allowed the ban to remain in place as the case proceeds.

It sets the stage for another massive Supreme Court showdown over Trump’s immigration crackdown. The justices are also mulling if Trump can deport migrants to countries where they have no ties and if authorities can indefinitely detain migrants without giving them access to a bond hearing.

The second case is Robinhood Markets v. Sodha , an investor lawsuit against the fintech company claiming it omitted key details about its business during its public offering amid the meme stock craze. The justices will sort out the standards for lawsuits under Section 11(a) of the Securities Act of 1933, and whether the accusations against Robinhood can proceed.

In a rather unusual move, the court rebuffed the Trump administration’s ask to take up its appeal in another hot-button legal battle, Trump v. Thakur.

A lower court has blocked the administration from cutting off grants to University of California researchers in response to Trump’s executive orders that seek to eliminate diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) policies.

The Supreme Court turned away Solicitor General D. John Sauer ’s ask to review the decision. Though the denial is far from unprecedented, the court often agrees to requests from the sitting administration.

The court provided no explanation for its decision, and no justice publicly dissented.

Separately, we have an update on two other petitions we told you to watch. The court won’t be taking them up, but a justice was writing an opinion behind the scenes. They dropped Monday:

Dive deeper here on why three conservative justices wanted to hear a free-speech challenge to California’s requirement that instructors teach doctors renewing their medical licenses about implicit bias.

And dive deeper here into the court’s decision to turn away a challenge to a Maryland gun law, and what Justice Clarence Thomas is signaling to Second Amendment advocates.

A federal judge in D.C. will hold a status conference in the criminal case against Rahmanullah Lakanwal , who is accused of shooting of two National Guard members who were on duty in the nation’s capital last year. Lakanwal has experienced several health-related setbacks while in jail, requiring him to be forcibly fed by prison officials.

Jeanine John Taele, who was arrested at Trump National Golf Club in Rancho Palos Verdes days before a planned visit by the president in early August, is set to appear in a Los Angeles courtroom for a hearing on whether he is mentally competent to stand trial on state weapons charges.

Influencer Andrew Tate will appear in a Miami courtroom for a hearing as he fights extradition to the United Kingdom on rape, assault, trafficking for sexual exploitation and other related charges.

A federal judge in New York will hold a hearing as Mohammad Baqer Saad Dawood Al-Saadi, one of three men accused of plotting nearly 20 terror attacks targeting U.S. citizens and Jewish communities in Europe, potentially seeks to represent himself in court.

A federal judge in D.C. will hear arguments as the Trump administration seeks to dissolve a preliminary injunction blocking the renaming and closure of the Kennedy Center.

Influencer Tristan Tate will appear in a Miami courtroom for a hearing as he fights extradition to the United Kingdom on rape, assault, trafficking for sexual exploitation and other related charges.

A federal judge in D.C. will hold a hearing to discuss pre-trial discovery in the case against Elias Rodriguez , the suspect charged in the fatal May 2025 shooting of two Israeli Embassy staffers outside the Capital Jewish Museum.

A federal judge in D.C. will hear arguments in a lawsuit filed by Arlington County, Va., that seeks to block construction of a 250-foot triumphal arch. The project has already been temporarily stopped in a separate case.

A federal judge in D.C. will hold a virtual status conference for updates in The American Federation of Teachers’ lawsuit against the Education Department for shutting down access to income-driven repayment plans for student borrowers.

A federal judge in D.C. will hear arguments in a lawsuit challenging the Education Department’s cuts to the Institute of Education Sciences which the Trump administration wants dismissed.

The Wall Street Journal’s Sadie Gurman and C. Ryan Barber : DOJ Is Ready to Battle Congress. A Texas Prosecutor Placed Himself at the Front.

The Washington Sun’s Michael Brice-Saddler : What the Logan Circle Shooter Told Me

Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

© 2026 Gigantum.net. Content gathered automatically from external sources; rights to each text belong to whoever originally published it.