'Our industry right now is laundering money' — With college sports in chaos, is a rev-share cap solution on the way?
A proposal from the SEC to impose financial penalties on schools for exceeding the athlete revenue-share cap is gaining traction across the four power league...
ARLINGTON, Va. — Each November, in or around the nation's capital, the Knight Commission holds an annual public meeting to discuss the state of college athletics.
Current and former college sports administrators and stakeholders gather in a room for about 90 minutes of conversations that, without failure, produce a jarring comment — or three.
With the industry at its most turbulent, this year's meeting did not disappoint.
The commissioner of the Ivy League suggested that high-resourced football programs should separate from the rest of Division I as "standalone, for-profit ventures"; an FCS athletic director turned his ire on the professional leagues to relax their eligibility rules, such as the NFL requiring high school players to spend three years in college; and, perhaps most notable of all, a recently retired power conference athletic director said the real quiet part aloud.
"Our industry right now is laundering money," said former Iowa State athletic director Jamie Pollard, one of the speakers at Tuesday's gathering in this Washington, D.C. suburb.
A stunning comment from such a recent high-profile figure, Pollard's description is one that many top school and conference officials have privately espoused to characterize the athlete compensation landscape: Schools are redirecting booster, sponsor and apparel money from the athletic department to their rosters disguised as marketing and endorsement deals in an effort to circumvent the enforcement operation.
However, as Pollard and other stakeholders here spoke, the gears churned behind the scenes to bring sweeping changes to the much-maligned system.
A proposal from the SEC to impose financial penalties on schools for exceeding the athlete revenue-share cap is gaining traction not only within the conference but across the four power leagues, those with knowledge of the discussion tell Yahoo Sports.
According to the proposal — reported in detail last week — schools spending more than the $21.6 million revenue-share cap stand to be assessed millions in penalties in a concept most similar to pro sports-style luxury tax structures. For instance, according to one model circulated, those spending $70.5 million would owe a tax of roughly $14 million — an amount that would increase significantly beyond that figure.
While the plan originated from the SEC, leaders in the other power conferences — the Big Ten, ACC and Big 12 — are coalescing around the concept to the point of adopting it soon and, perhaps, communicating their plans with the co-lead plaintiff attorneys in the House settlement, Jeffrey Kessler and Steve Berman. Both attorneys have suggested that such a cap policy may unnecessarily restrict athlete pay and have expressed doubt that it is legal without their approval under the House settlement — the NCAA's multi-billion dollar agreement that governs the industry's new athlete compensation system.
During and after the Knight Commission meeting, Anil Gollahalli, the Big Ten's chief legal officer and general counsel, discussed the Big Ten's own cap policy — passed last month — and the one circulated from the SEC. He said the two are "distinctly different." The Big Ten's rule only applies to those within the league, while the SEC's proposal — possibly now embraced by all power conferences and administered by the College Sports Commission — may necessitate crossing other legal hurdles.
"You have to draw a distinction about what conferences can do by themselves versus what leagues can do collectively and perhaps in connection with [House plaintiff attorneys]," Gollahalli told Yahoo Sports. "I can't comment on what the right mechanisms are because I don't know what the contours of the proposal will finally end up being."
Described as a "Plan B" if Congress does not pass federal legislation to regulate the industry — seemingly a longshot at this point — the cap policy circulated by the SEC features a tiered system of gradually increasing fines for those exceeding the revenue-share cap. Fines would begin at less than 1% of overages for those spending $22-$50.5 million on their rosters, and then increase to 1% for those spending $50.5-60.5 million, then to 3% for those spending $60.5-70.5 million and, finally, to 10% for those spending more than $70.5 million.
However, penalty figure amounts continue to be an ongoing conversation among administrators and are subject to change.
The cap policy's intent is clear: slow spending by charging schools additional revenue. But some of the richest programs in the country — i.e. Texas, Ohio State, Miami, etc. — may continue to lap the college football spending field despite the penalty.
"They'll just pay the fine," says one major conference athletic director.
Money was at the center of Tuesday's Knight Commission meeting. At the top level of major college football, schools are believed to be spending more than $40 million on their football rosters and some exceeding more than $15 million for men's basketball.
University officials are in the midst of negotiations to land high school prospects, re-sign their current players and target potential transfers in a hotly competitive recruiting market that is expected to increase by as much or more than 30% during this cycle.
To that end, on Tuesday, Ivy League commissioner Robin Harris made a somewhat bold and revolutionary statement: Perhaps those rich football powers should go do their own thing.
"Call a spade a spade," Harris told Yahoo Sports. "They are operating as revenue-producing entities for profit. And they are paying athletes a lot of money and paying coaches a lot of money. It should be a standalone, but yet affiliated, for-profit venture. They are operated as taxable entities but are still affiliated with the institutions. You have to have a different structure and rules. What that looks like, I don't know."
She is perhaps referencing the long-discussed split of the power leagues, or perhaps even a smaller group of high-revenue producing football programs. A split into a "semi-pro model" would bring "reality and rational choices" to the schools outside of those leagues that are "overspending and can't afford it," she said.
"They are chasing something that they cannot obtain," Harris said. "Now they would free up dollars to be put to the greater good."
But even those in the power leagues are struggling to keep pace with their blue-blood brethren, says Pollard. He condemned college leaders for making short-term decisions that have "long-term consequences" and believes that university presidents and their boards are making "irrational and emotional" decisions in shifting campus funds to athletics where they are "no way going to be repaid."
College leaders are taking out loans for athletics to be paid back with revenue from new television deals, he says. But he does not believe some of those new media deals — such as one in his former conference, the Big 12 — will be lucrative enough to pay back those loans.
"I come from a conference that as late as two years ago our commissioner told our board, 'If I can't get you 2.5 times in 2031 [the value] from our television deal, I should be fired,'" Pollard said.
"We'll be lucky to get 1 times," he said. "Think about that. We're making decisions today about revenue in the future that's most likely not going to be there."
But perhaps the money-washing that Pollard referenced in his opening comments Tuesday may subside with a new cap policy.
The concept would consider some school-affiliated, third-party NIL deals as "institutional pay," such as a redirecting of revenues from corporate sponsors, multi-media rights partners and perhaps even apparel brands. This would remove the requirement for schools to gain approval from the College Sports Commission's NIL Go clearinghouse for NIL agreements with such entities — what is now a time-consuming and resource-draining measure to circumvent the existing cap by paying as much as 20% to third-party entities to "wash money," as officials describe it.
But college executives believe a cap policy would not be necessary if Congress would pass the Protect College Sports Act, the all-encompassing college sports bill that overwhelmingly passed the Senate but faces a stiff test in the House of Representatives.
Steve Eigenbrot, a former South Carolina administrator who is the athletic director at FCS Towson, offered a different suggestion for the congressional lobbying effort. He believes the federal government should examine professional league-eligibility rules that prevent high school or early college athletes from earning compensation at the NFL level.
"Maurice Clarett famously won a court case and then he didn't," he said of the former Ohio State running back who was denied early entrance in the NFL. "Had that moment changed, I think we would be looking at this problem very differently."
One of the NCAA's senior vice presidents, Tim Buckley, told the Knight Commission on Tuesday that the NCAA is "the closest we've ever been" to having legislation passed. And while that's true, many view it as a longshot in a House chamber that may run out of time before a new Congress arrives in January. There are only three more full working weeks remaining in the congressional calendar.
For the legislation to pass the House in a "traditional way," it is "highly unlikely to get to the finish line" because of the calendar, said Rob Mangus, a subject-matter expert for the Knight Commission who gave an update on the bill Tuesday.
"There just isn't enough time to do it," he told the room. "Is there going to be a vote at all? Some people think not."
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.