An Ohio homeowner who lived in his house for more than 20 years arrested for trespassing after two guests claimed it was their home; the charges were dropped but he is suing the city for alleged civil rights violations
An Ohio homeowner who had owned his house for more than 20 years was arrested for trespassing after a dispute with two people he had temporarily allowed
An Ohio homeowner who had owned his house for more than 20 years was arrested for trespassing after a dispute with two people he had temporarily allowed to stay there. The guests allegedly claimed they lived in the property rather than the homeowner, leading to a police response that ended with his arrest. The criminal charge was eventually dismissed, but the incident has since resulted in a federal lawsuit against the city and two police officers, raising questions about how authorities handled the property dispute.Ohio homeowner end up arrested for trespassing in his own houseThe incident involved Eric Freed, a doctor from Belpre, Ohio, who said he had owned a house on Campbell Drive for more than two decades. According to a report by WTAP published on July 1, 2026, Freed had allowed a woman, Monika Parkinson, and her brother, Pawel, to stay at the property temporarily while renovation work was taking place.The arrangement was informal. Freed maintained that neither sibling paid rent, signed a tenancy agreement or contributed financially towards the property. He also said there was no landlord-tenant relationship between them and that he remained free to visit the house whenever he needed to.However, the situation reportedly deteriorated after disagreements developed between Freed and the siblings. According to the lawsuit details reported by WOUB Public Media on June 26, 2026, Freed alleged that Pawel repeatedly smoked marijuana inside the house despite being asked to stop. The smell reportedly became noticeable enough for other family members to complain.When Freed confronted Pawel about the issue and asked him to leave, the brother allegedly responded that he and Monika lived there, not Freed. The disagreement eventually turned into a dispute over who had the right to enter and occupy the property.What happened before the police arrested FreedThe disagreement did not immediately result in an arrest. According to WOUB, the siblings contacted police twice in the days before the incident to report Freed's presence at the house. Freed said he was unaware of those calls and that no officers had contacted him about the complaints.When deputies arrived following another call, Freed explained that he owned the property and had the right to be there. The officers reportedly treated the disagreement as a civil matter and advised him that he would need to follow the legal eviction process to remove the guests.According to the lawsuit, one deputy explained that Freed needed to provide a three-day notice as the first step towards having Pawel leave the property. Freed subsequently hired an attorney, who prepared the notice to vacate and reportedly confirmed that he had the legal right to enter his own house.WTAP reported that Freed posted the formal notice on the property's door. However, the disagreement continued despite the attempt to resolve the matter through the recommended legal procedure.What led to the June 9 arrestOn June 9, 2025, Freed returned to the house to check on a problem involving a sump pump in the basement. According to WOUB, Monika called Belpre police after he arrived, following earlier advice from officers to contact them whenever he returned to the property. By the time police reached the house, Freed had already left.He returned later that day to inspect the sump pump again and mow the lawn. On entering the property, he discovered that a chain lock had been installed on the front door without his permission. He removed it before entering.WTAP reported that another call was then made to the police. According to the lawsuit, officers entered the house without a warrant. Freed said he informed them that he was the homeowner, showed his driving licence listing the property as his address and offered to let them contact his attorney to verify his ownership.However, he alleged that officers handcuffed him before he could produce the relevant documents or have his lawyer contacted.Freed was arrested and charged with criminal trespass. The charge alleged that he had knowingly entered or remained on premises belonging to Monika Parkinson without permission, according to WOUB.What happened after Freed was taken into custodyThe arrest was followed by several hours in police custody. According to WOUB, Freed was initially held at the Belpre police station for approximately 4 hours before being transported to Washington County Jail for booking.His lawsuit also alleges that officers seized his mobile phone without a warrant. The device was particularly important to him because he used it for his medical practice and patient communications. Freed reportedly said officers repeatedly asked him to provide his phone's access code while he was at the station, but he refused.The phone was eventually returned approximately a week after the arrest, according to WOUB.Freed also faced difficulties getting home after his release. Without his phone, he had no easy way to arrange transportation. The lawsuit states that police dispatch offered to retrieve telephone numbers for him if he provided his phone access code.Instead, Freed began walking towards his house. WOUB reported that he walked approximately 14 miles over four hours before a Washington County sheriff's deputy offered him a lift for the remaining distance. The criminal trespass charge was subsequently dismissed in September 2025, around 3 months after the arrest, according to WTAP.Why is the Ohio homeowner now suing the cityThe dismissal of the criminal charge did not end the matter. In late April 2026, Freed filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the City of Belpre, police officer Gunnar Smith and Sergeant Joe Fields, according to WOUB. The lawsuit alleges that the officers unlawfully deprived him of his freedom by arresting him at a property he owned.WTAP reported that Freed is pursuing claims including false arrest, malicious prosecution and other alleged civil rights violations. He is seeking financial damages as well as changes to police training on how officers handle property disputes. The lawsuit now places the circumstances of the arrest under federal scrutiny.You use AI every day. Now get your AI Quotient. Take the AIQ test.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.