High-Yield Dividend Investors Could Be Making This Expensive Tax Mistake

NLY yields 13.1% and AGNC pays monthly, but both distribute entirely as ordinary income, costing taxable-account holders roughly $10,200 annually per $500,000.

BDCs like ARCC and MAIN flow distributions as ordinary income, making account location as consequential as security selection for high-bracket investors.

Reinvesting the $10,200 annual Roth advantage at 6% over 20 years compounds into a permanently larger gap a taxable account can never recover.

Just released. Our analysts combed the entire stock market and named the ten best stocks to buy right now, and Realty Income didn't make the cut. Enter your email to see the names that beat O. The report is free. Enter your email and see if any of your stocks made the cut.

At the 24% federal bracket, a portfolio generating $40,000 in ordinary-income dividends hands roughly $9,600 to the IRS every year. That is the recurring cost of holding high-yield REITs, mortgage REITs, and BDCs in a taxable brokerage instead of a Roth IRA, and the bill arrives every April for as long as the positions exist. The six names below all distribute income taxed at ordinary rates, which is why account location can matter as much as security selection.

Roth Versus Taxable on the Same $500,000 Sleeve

Assume a $500,000 equal-weighted basket of the six tickers listed, producing a blended yield of roughly 8.5%. Gross annual income lands near $42,500. Inside a Roth, the investor keeps all of it. In a taxable account at the 24% bracket, ordinary-income tax carves out about $10,200, leaving $32,300 net. That $10,200 annual delta is the Roth advantage, and over 10 years without any reinvestment it is $102,000 of income that either stays with the shareholder or does not.

The individual holdings, current yields, and why each belongs specifically in a Roth:

24/7 Wall St has helped investors make money for over two decades, and our top analysts just finished ranking the definitive Top 10 Stocks To Buy Now . Not the ten biggest companies. Not the ten everyone is arguing about. The ten best stocks to buy right now.

The report is free, and you can see why we think each stock is a top investment today.

Realty Income ( NYSE:O ): monthly payer at 5.00%, with an annualized forward distribution of $3.252 against a $61.74 share price. Net-lease REIT distributions are non-qualified ordinary income.

Simon Property Group ( NYSE:SPG ): quarterly dividend annualized at $9.00 against $211.52, a yield near 4.3%. Same REIT tax treatment as O.

Annaly Capital Management ( NYSE:NLY ): mortgage REIT paying $3.00 annualized against $22.83, roughly 13.1%. mREIT payouts are almost entirely ordinary income.

AGNC Investment ( NASDAQ:AGNC ): monthly $0.12 per share, $1.44 annualized against $10.66. Highest-priority Roth candidate given the yield.

Ares Capital ( NASDAQ:ARCC ): BDC paying $0.48 quarterly, $1.92 annualized against $20.01, near 9.6%. BDC distributions flow through as ordinary income.

Main Street Capital ( NYSE:MAIN ): regular monthly $0.265 plus a $0.30 supplemental in Q2 2026, against $58.07. Regular distribution runs near 5.5% before supplementals.