Meta brings fight over Washington state campaign ad law to Supreme Court
Meta is asking the Supreme Court to hear its challenge to a Washington state law requiring that social media companies answer public requests for information about the political advertisements shown on their platforms. The company, which owns Facebook and Instagram, said in a petition docketed Wednesday the law is “virtually unprecedented” and violates the First…
Meta is asking the Supreme Court to hear its challenge to a Washington state law requiring that social media companies answer public requests for information about the political advertisements shown on their platforms.
The company, which owns Facebook and Instagram, said in a petition docketed Wednesday the law is “virtually unprecedented” and violates the First Amendment by unreasonably restricting political speech.
“Had Washington simply banned political ads from digital platforms altogether, that would be an obvious First Amendment violation,” Meta’s lawyers wrote in court filings. “The result should be no different when a state achieves the same end via the most burdensome political-ad disclosure regime in the Nation.”
Washington amended its Fair Campaign Practices Act in 2018 to require that Meta and other “digital communication platforms” collect demographic, impression and audience data for qualifying political ads in the state. Upon a request, they must provide the information within two business days. Penalties for not doing so can reach up to $30,000 per violation.
The state attorney general’s office, which declined to comment on Meta’s latest filing, has defended the law in court by saying it’s necessary to inform voters.
Meta responded by banning political ads in the state, though the company has since conceded that some records requests had slipped through and that it didn’t adequately respond to these inquiries from members of the public.
Washington sued the tech giant, and a state judge ordered Meta to pay nearly $25 million plus legal fees. It’s appealing the decision after its arguments fell flat before Washington’s top court.
The Supreme Court chooses which cases it hears and turns away the vast majority of petitions. The justices are likely to consider Meta’s request at a closed-door meeting later in the term.
The company is represented by Paul Clement, a veteran Supreme Court advocate who served as former President George W. Bush’s top representative before the court.
Clement said the First Amendment concerns with Washington’s law couldn’t be “overstated” and told the justices their intervention is needed to resolve a split with a court that considered similar law in Maryland and ruled the other way.
“Shutting down political speech in ways that are not politically neutral is as antithetical to First Amendment values as it gets,” Clement wrote in court filings. “And our Constitution does not permit states to impose prohibitive compelled-speech mandates on media companies and then fine them tens of millions of dollars when they inevitably cannot perfectly comply.”
The Washington attorney’s general office declined to comment on Meta’s appeal and pointed to its existing court papers.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.