Murkowski joins Democrats in concerns about Project 2025 author’s nomination to be Interior watchdog
Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) joined Democrats in raising concerns about President Trump’s unusually political pick to lead the Interior Department’s nonpartisan watchdog office during his confirmation hearing on Wednesday. Murkowski raised objections brought by the department’s last inspector general (IG) — whom Trump fired in a purge of such watchdogs last year — to his…
Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) joined Democrats in raising concerns about President Trump’s unusually political pick to lead the Interior Department’s nonpartisan watchdog office during his confirmation hearing on Wednesday.
Murkowski raised objections brought by the department’s last inspector general (IG) — whom Trump fired in a purge of such watchdogs last year — to his new nominee for the role, Dennis Kirk.
Kirk’s nomination has proved particularly contentious because he has held political positions, including in the White House Office of Personnel Management during Trump’s first term. He was also a co-author of one of the chapters of Project 2025, the controversial blueprint for a conservative administration written by the Heritage Foundation.
“The former inspector general, Mark Greenblatt … I just want you to respond to a comment that he has made about your nomination. This is your opportunity to tell us why you think you should deserve to get this job,” Murkowski told Kirk during Wednesday’s Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee hearing.
“His quote is: ‘Inspectors general must be able to investigate the administration that appointed them without fear or favor. Mr. Kirk’s political background and close ties to this administration make it impossible for him to credibly meet that fundamental test.’” the senator continued.
She added that inspectors general play a “critical role” that must be done with “an unbiased view, impartiality, looking at what you have in front of you without tipping the scale one way or another with political favor.”
In response, Kirk said, “If confirmed, I guarantee you that I will implement absolutely independent oversight, excellence, integrity, and accountability.”
“The IG has the obligation to identify the risks, the vulnerabilities that impact all of the things that happen. To complete this mission, I commit to doing that exact thing: performing audits, investigations, evaluations, and giving those reports to Congress directly,” he added.
If every Democrat opposes the nomination, it could still pass with up to three Republicans in opposition. It is unclear whether Murkowski will ultimately oppose Kirk or whether other Republicans might join her.
If he has any shot at confirmation, Republicans will have to advance and vote on his nomination before Democrats retake the Senate majority in January.
He will face another hearing along with a slate of other nominees before the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee on Thursday.
Greenblatt told The Hill that “it certainly seems like they are going to try to jam him in” with the back-to-back hearings.
During the Energy and Natural Resources hearing, several Democrats raised concerns similar to Murkowski’s.
Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-Hawaii) asked the nominee if he would reassure lawmakers that he would do his job “without fear or favor?”
“I really enjoy what I do. I do it for everybody. I have served six presidents, including multiple other party presidents. I’ve never had a problem from any president I’ve served, or objections, or being accused of being political,” Kirk said.
“I think it is very clear that you are working for a president who expects loyalty. Would you agree with that?” Hirono said.
“I would hope everybody who serves the president under our Constitution remembers that the taxpayers and the Constitution allowed people to get people into office, and under our system, we vote for the person who makes policies and promises,” Kirk said.
“Excuse me, but you are working for a president who does not believe that the rule of law applies to him,” Hirono replied.
Kirk indicated he has not had such experiences and has never met Trump.
“Do you not watch the news or read the papers?” Hirono asked. “It is very clear that this president does not believe the rule of law applies to him.”
Meanwhile, citing a report that officials hold tech investments while pursuing data centers on public lands, Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.) asked, “As a person who would be in charge with preventing that waste, fraud, abuse and mismanagement, looking at inappropriate conflicts of interest, would it be your obligation to open an investigation into whether employees of the Interior Department are financially benefiting from the investments they have in these data management companies?”
In response, Kirk said, “It is our office’s position to identify those kinds of risks and look at those kinds of questions and I have a very trusted staff and I think that as those things come up to us, you can…be assured we will look independently and objectively at all that.”
“So that’s a yes, you will investigate it?” Cortez Masto asked.
The nominee said he couldn’t “commit” to the investigation, but he would “in good faith, be responsive to those questions and look at things that arise to those kinds of issues that are waste, fraud, abuse of the public fisc. I am a fiscal budget transformation kind of a guy. I am concerned about the taxpayer dollars.”
“Good. So am I, and that even includes this administration if they’re abusing taxpayer dollars. You’d be willing to look into that?” Cortez Masto continued.
Possibly confusing her question for a statement, Kirk replied, “Thank you.”
“OK. Thank you, a nonanswer,” Cortez Masto said.
After the hearing, Greenblatt called Kirk’s performance “uninspiring.”
“He mouthed the words of independence, but it seemed like an afterthought more than a core commitment,” the former inspector general said.
He had previously raised concerns the appointment could jeopardize the independence of the watchdog’s investigations and could compromise the identities of whistleblowers.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.