Americans don’t care about beating China’s AI; we’d rather have safety
Americans want guardrails, even at the expense of beating China.
The midterm elections made clear that Americans are upset with the move fast and break things approach of the artificial intelligence race, and the issue can decide elections. Voters in at least 38 places embraced data center bans and restrictions, and 56 percent of voters said AI and data centers were a crucial or major factor in their votes.
And yet, every week brings news of another AI safety incident: a model behaving in surprising, dangerous, possibly illegal ways. Companies keep racing to release more powerful models. As OpenAI CEO Sam Altman put it , “the world should accept some bad things happening” in exchange for AI’s benefits.
Why so little action in Washington? Part of the answer is money and power: trillion-dollar companies, a stock market high on AI supply, an administration cozy with Silicon Valley. But opponents of serious regulation don’t say that out loud. Instead, they point to China.
Earlier this month, President Trump said of the AI race with China, “whoever wins that race wins.” Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei warns that letting China race ahead would hand it “geopolitical dominance.” Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) put it most bluntly : “If there are gonna be killer robots, I’d rather they be American killer robots than Chinese killer robots.”
In other words, we must race to build technology that could hurt us before China builds it. That logic doesn’t hold up, and even if the China threat is real, it is no reason to delay protecting Americans.
First, the race assumes that whoever reaches advanced AI first wins. No one can explain what that winning capability would be. China already holds formidable cyber, military and economic tools and largely refrains from using them to cripple American interests because it expects a devastating response.
As a Foreign Affairs story notes , Beijing cut off U.S. access to critical minerals only after the Trump administration launched a tariff war and expanded export controls. China will press any advantage new technology offers, as every country does. But American deterrence won’t vanish, and Beijing knows a rupture would be devastating.
Second, the race assumes American AI will be safer than Chinese AI. But the companies don’t fully understand or control what they are building. Their own employees warn of existential stakes; one researcher who recently left Anthropic said the people building AI “earnestly believe that it could kill us all by the end of the decade.” Technology we don’t control is not loyal to Washington or Beijing.
Third, the race assumes the two AI ecosystems advance independently. China’s AI innovation is real, as DeepSeek’s 2025 breakthrough and the popularity of Chinese apps in the U.S. show. But the frontiers are intertwined: U.S. export controls limit China’s access to advanced chips, Chinese firms have trained their models on the outputs of American ones and Chinese companies rely on U.S. cloud providers . Tougher American restrictions would slow China down.
Finally, Americans want guardrails, even at the expense of beating China. By 61 percent to 20 percent, they would rather be protected from AI harms than beat China. Trump voters agree, 44 percent to 31 percent. In fact, beating China ranks among Americans’ least important AI concerns.
Because the world’s leading AI companies are American, Washington can regulate much of the frontier on its own. It should start by pausing frontier development until strong safeguards ensure human control and challenges America has barely begun to confront are addressed.
That includes massive job losses, threats to civil liberties, the strain of data centers on communities, the exploitation of workers at home and abroad, and the extraordinary power these companies hold over the economy and everyday life. We also need new laws and immediate enforcement of existing ones, including holding companies responsible for the harms their products cause.
People in America and around the world, not a handful of tech executives, should decide how this technology enters their lives, guided by respect for human dignity and human rights. And the frontier isn’t the only race. China has prioritized diffusing AI throughout its economy ; the United States should focus far more on using the technology in ways that actually benefit people.
None of this means ignoring China. Beijing isn’t ignoring AI’s dangers. It increasingly fears threats to political stability and already regulates AI domestically and is imposing its own export controls . U.S. policy toward China should be driven by safety, too. That means considering export controls that slow any company’s race to the frontier and working with China and others on incident reporting and an international safety accord.
A serious U.S.-China agreement won’t come soon, but an American pause, in America’s own interest, would show a skeptical Beijing that Washington is serious. There is precedent. America’s unilateral renunciation of biological weapons in 1969 helped spur others to follow, eventually producing the Biological Weapons Convention .
We don’t fully understand this technology, but we decide how it is built and deployed. Fear of China should not propel us to build something we know is dangerous. If America can lead the world in AI innovation, it can lead in AI safety too.
Michael Fuchs is the director of US Foreign Policy at the Open Society Foundations. He served as special assistant to President Joe Biden, deputy chief of Staff to Vice President Kamala Harris, deputy assistant secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs in the Obama administration and special assistant to Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.