Schar Gets 7, Barnes With 5.5 | Newcastle United Players Rated In Tough Loss Vs Everton

Newcastle United entertained Everton at St. James' Park earlier tonight as they hoped to secure a good result at home in the Premier League. The Magpies made a decent start to the game and managed to get to the half-time break with a 0-0 scoreline.

Thierno Barry scored the opener for the Merseyside club in the 49th minute. Jacob Ramsey was sent off by the referee in injury time as the contest finished with Matthias Jaissle's men suffering a tough 1-0 loss in front of their home fans.

Let's take a look at how each Newcastle United player fared during the clash against the Toffees.

He made a few solid saves at the back but made a costly error tonight.

Dedic made a couple of important clearances inside his half and made two decent chances going forward.

He cleared his lines when he could and was a threat at the other end of the field.

Burn put his foot through the ball when required and was a strong presence in the air.

NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE, ENGLAND – NOVEMBER 02: Referee John Brooks shows a second yellow card, followed by a red card to Jacob Ramsey of Newcastle United during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Newcastle United and Everton at St James' Park on November 02, 2026 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England. (Photo by George Wood/Getty Images)

He came back to defend when needed and made one decent chance in the final third.

Gonzalez anchored the midfield well at times but failed to influence the game going forward.

He worked hard on both halves but has nothing to show for his efforts.

Elanga caught the eye at times and was unfortunate to hit the post.

He caused a few problems for the Everton defenders but failed to threaten their goal.

Barnes struggled to get into the flow of the game and never looked like he would score.

Osula made one key chance in the final third but failed to register a goal.

He was a threat after coming off the bench.

Steur made two good chances in the final third.

He let his teammates down by getting sent off in injury time.

He made two decent chances from the right flank.