Judge rips LSU attorneys amid SEC eligibility lawsuit: 'You put the pig out there'
A federal judge slammed attorneys representing LSU in court on Wednesday, one day after the Tigers added RJ Luis to their basketball roster.
A federal judge laid into lawyers representing LSU on Wednesday after the university claimed the SEC had "hallucinated" citations in a court filing.
Judge Annemarie Carney Axon demanded a retraction from the school and a "heartfelt" public statement expressing regret for using language that bashed the character of opposing attorneys, according to ESPN's Alex Scarborough . The hearing on Wednesday had to do with a previous filing regarding LSU's language, which had accused the SEC of supplying or hallucinating case citations, amid the larger legal battle between the university and the conference.
The SEC called the statement "scandalous and professionally insulting." Axon repeatedly questioned LSU attorney Bruce Rogers, who later admitted "they're not made-up cases." Rogers claimed the cases were only hallucinated because they didn't support the SEC's argument, and that they weren't calling out the lawyers directly.
Axon, however, said that was the "opposite" of what was written in his brief.
"You wouldn't want somebody to wrongly accuse you of hallucinating a case, knowing full well what the implication of that accusation is," Axon said, via ESPN.
Rogers then tried to argue that there was a broader definition to "hallucinated."
"We're not dressing this up, OK?" Axon replied. "You put the pig out there. There's no time for you to put lipstick on it."
Axon eventually told Rogers he could file a motion to remove the term "hallucinated" from the previous filing, but that it should include that it exhibited "poor professional judgement." Rogers, LSU and the attorney general's office must also issue "heartfelt" and "robust" public statements.
"I have to tell you, I'm so disappointed," Axon said. "If this happens one more time, you're going to be sanctioned to the fullest extent I can."
Despite the judge's orders, Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murril said she would not be apologizing.
"I cannot and will not apologize for my lawyers doing their job, and it is improper for an Alabama federal judge to compel speech from the state of Louisiana," she said . "The SEC made an egregious citation error. Their inability to explain that error is their problem, not Louisiana's."
LSU and the SEC have been in a legal battle for months now over the ability to play professional athletes.
Three players who had been rostered in NFL training camps earlier in the summer were legally cleared to join the Tigers' roster, which led to the SEC ruling that it could punish the Tigers for doing so — including via game boycotts or even expulsion from the league. The Tigers didn't end up including the three players in question on the football roster. The SEC filed a lawsuit against LSU in September over its attempts to play the three players.
But on Tuesday, LSU basketball added former Big East Player of the Year RJ Luis Jr. to its roster. Luis had played three preseason games for the Boston Celtics in 2025 after going undrafted out of St. John's, though he never played in a regular-season NBA game.
Luis was granted multiple temporary injunctions, including one on Friday that stated the SEC and NCAA could not legally penalize LSU for adding Luis to its roster. The SEC informed LSU on Monday that it wouldn't seek to punish the school.
But after LSU added Luis on Tuesday, the SEC called the decision "deeply concerning and disappointing."
"LSU's decision today to rely on its own interpretation of the court's order to justify its actions is inconsistent with the expectations and responsibilities of membership in the Southeastern Conference," the statement said. "This is a deeply concerning and disappointing development. The conference will continue to uphold and defend the standards and policies established by its member universities."
LSU football coach Lane Kiffin was asked about the developments on Wednesday, too, and wanted nothing to do with it.
"In no planet am I touching that," Kiffin said, via Michael Bratton of "That SEC Podcast."
Clearly, this legal battle between LSU and the SEC is far from over. LSU has attempted to have it dismissed, but the SEC has claimed that attempts to resolve it privately have failed.
Whether Luis actually sees the court with the Tigers, however, remains to be seen.
Later on Wednesday afternoon, the Georiga attorney general got involved and slammed LSU in a letter to SEC commissioner Greg Sankey.
Attorney General Christopher Carr called LSU out for a "pattern of destructive behavior," and encouraged the league to sanction LSU — "up to and including expulsion" from the league completely.
"Put simply, LSU is again attempting to benefit from the legal chaos it helped to coordinate and encourage," Carr wrote, via ESPN . "LSU's continued contempt for the rules of the SEC — rules they have voted on and agreed to — cannot go unaddressed.
"Put simply, LSU is again attempting to benefit from the legal chaos it helped to coordinate and encourage," Carr wrote, via ESPN .
"LSU's continued contempt for the rules of the SEC — rules they have voted on and agreed to — cannot go unaddressed.
This is the second such letter that Carr has written the SEC about LSU.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.