Would you share your data for public good?
When a website asks you to accept its cookies, odds are you do it without much thought.
When a website asks you to accept its cookies, odds are you do it without much thought. What was meant to be a data privacy safeguard has become an empty ritual. But what if such privacy laws are counterproductive in ways that we have not considered? That’s the contrarian claim Omri Ben-Shahar, a University of Chicago law professor, makes in his book Why Fear Data.Ben-Shaharargues that these laws have misdiagnosed the problem. Yes, they shield individuals from intrusion, which is a private harm, but they pay little attention to the possible good that masses of data could deliver. Those gains, he says, would be enormous, measured in lives, injuries and dollars rather than convenience. He explains this with examples.Take roads first. Every year, more than 40,000 Americans die in road accidents, which is about a fourth of road deaths in India annually. Would drivers be more careful if they could save on insurance premiums? Experience shows they are. Where insurers offer opt-in policies that track how you drive – hard braking, sharp turns, phone use – and cut premiums for safe drivers, fatal accidents are around 30% lower among those who are tracked.In US, such policies can potentially save 12,000 lives a year. Only if you are willing to share your data with insurers. But Ben-Shaharsays state govts have created hurdles for such data sharing. California, for example, bans tracking anything beyond miles driven, and some states stop insurers from using texting data against drivers.Facial recognition is another intrusive tech that can do good, he argues. In US, a facial recognition tool is said to have helped identify over 18,000 trafficking victims. In India, another app called Darpan reportedly helped rescue over 3,000 missing children in a month-long operation in 2020.But you can’t use this tech in EU, where scraping faces off the internet is banned. Critics say such software is responsible for wrongful arrests of Black men, but that problem also arises from a paucity of training data. If privacy rules are relaxed, to train AI on better quality data, the mistakes will reduce.Ben-Shahar’sthird example is about health records. In Malawi, he says, digitising HIV patients’ files cut deaths by 28% within five years – preventing over 5,000 deaths. However, the HIV death rate could have fallen more had many patients not opted out of digitisation on privacy grounds.Denying access to patient data slows down research also. For example, consent for follow-up data analysis fell from 96% to 34% once America’s HIPAA rules demanded formal consent. By one estimate, an eight-month delay to a 1980s heart attack drug trial, caused by consent paperwork, cost some 9,000 lives.Ben-Shaharconsiders this a case of precaution run amok. Privacy, once valued as a means to a good life, has become an end in itself – he calls it privacy fundamentalism. To a large extent, fear of China’s surveillance state, rumoured to be hungry for everybody’s data, is used as a bogeyman for hermetic data privacy laws. He clarifies that he doesn’t consider privacyworthless, but urges everyone to weigh both sides of the ledger. Because a law that counts only the harms of data sharing will always say no.Disclaimer: Views expressed above are the author's own.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.