Psychology says a cluttered home may be linked to more than visual mess; a 2025 study of 501 adults associated household clutter with lower psychological well-being and life satisfaction
Household clutter was linked with lower psychological well-being in a 2025 study of 501 adults.
Household clutter was linked with lower psychological well-being in a 2025 study of 501 adults. The survey by Francis Quinn collected data from May 2020 to November 2021. According to the study published in ScienceDirect, titled ‘Home clutter and mental well-being: Exploring moderators and the mediating role of home beauty’, people who rated their homes as more cluttered reported lower mental well-being, lower life satisfaction and less positive feeling, along with more negative feeling. The author reports that how beautiful people found their home explained part of this link. The study did not measure restlessness, and the author states that a survey like this cannot show that clutter causes lower well-being.How researchers studied clutter and psychological well-beingAccording to the study, the research was an online survey carried out between May 2020 and November 2021, during the COVID-19 pandemic. It was advertised on participant recruitment websites and in a university's weekly email to students and staff. Anyone over 16 who understood English could take part. Three people who gave no information apart from their country were removed before the analysis. The paper says participants were offered entry into a prize draw for one of three £40 Amazon.com gift vouchers.The 501 participants were 80% women, 19% men and 1% another gender identity, aged from 16 to 92, with an average age of 33. According to the author, 33% were full-time students, 42% were renters, and 31% were self-isolating because of COVID. Most lived in the UK (84%), with smaller numbers elsewhere in Europe (5%), Asia (3%) and North America (3%). The survey asked people to rate how cluttered their homes were, including by room: the living room, bedroom, kitchen and bathroom. It also asked about their positive and negative feelings, their mental well-being, and how satisfied they were with life overallClutter was linked to lower life satisfaction and well-beingAccording to the study, the link between clutter and well-being pointed the same way every time. People who rated their homes as more cluttered reported lower mental well-being, lower life satisfaction and less positive feeling, along with more negative feeling. The paper gives figures for one of its two clutter measures: −.27 with mental well-being, −.26 with life satisfaction, −.22 with positive feelings and .25 with negative feelings. The author describes all of these links as small, and they were statistically significant.The paper says the same pattern held in its path model, where the effects were small to modest and clutter explained only about 6% to 7% of the variance in each outcome. The discussion notes that earlier studies, including Rogers and Hart (2021) and Roster et al. (2016), found medium-sized effects. The author suggests that the difference may come from who was recruited. According to the paper, some earlier studies drew many people who were interested in clutter or struggling with it, while this one took a more general approach to recruitment.How home beauty influenced the link between clutter and well-beingAccording to the paper, this was the first time that how beautiful people find their home had been tested as a link between clutter and well-being. Participants rated one statement, "The interior of my home is beautiful". The study found that people with more clutter tended to rate their homes as less beautiful. It also found that people who rated their homes as more beautiful tended to report better well-being, for example, a link of .43 with life satisfaction and .40 with positive feelings.The author reports that home beauty explained part of the connection between clutter and well-being, but not all of it. The direct links from clutter to well-being stayed significant, only smaller. The paper also says that people's general ability to appreciate beauty made no clear difference to these results. The author calls the home beauty finding tentative, partly because it relied on a single survey question, and says future work needs a longer set of questions to confirm it.Why clutter's link to well-being may not prove cause and effectResearchers also checked whether the clutter link differed between groups of people, including by age, gender, income, student status, time spent at home and intention to declutter. There were 32 possible differences to test, and only one came out as significant: time at home at weekends and its effect on positive feelings. The author writes that this does not appear likely to be a genuine effect, given the number of tests run and its very small size.The author states that a survey like this cannot show that clutter causes lower well-being. The paper says the data cannot rule out the opposite explanation: that people with lower well-being may let clutter build up. It also notes that the data were collected during the pandemic and that everything was self-reported. According to the abstract, the findings "are exploratory and require replication using longitudinal and/or experimental designs". The author says the results are consistent with the possibility that the home environment could affect well-being, though caution is needed about cause and effect.You use AI every day. Now get your AI Quotient. Take the AIQ testGet the latest Lifestyle News and more. Download the TOI app.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.