Houston police officer crashes into woman's car, leaving her with a broken leg; city denies compensation claim, then auctions the car for just $10; woman says she has lost her independence
A Houston woman who relied on her car as both a home and a place to keep her most treasured possessions says she was left without compensation after a
A Houston woman who relied on her car as both a home and a place to keep her most treasured possessions says she was left without compensation after a police officer crashed into her vehicle. The situation became even more distressing when the damaged car was later declared abandoned and sold at an auction for just $10, without her knowledge, according to an investigation by ABC13 Houston.Kimberly Ezike said her vehicle was her lifeline when she was between places. It also contained some of her most valuable belongings, including the ashes of her late mother. But an accident on August 26, 2024, changed her circumstances, leaving her with a broken leg, no vehicle and an ongoing dispute with the city over compensation.Police officer's car crash left Kimberly Ezike injuredThe accident happened on Harwin Drive near Gessner Road in Houston. According to the Texas Department of Transportation crash report cited by ABC13 Houston, a Houston Police Department (HPD) officer responding to a burglary call struck Ezike's vehicle from behind.The impact pushed her car over the curb and into an electrical pole. Ezike suffered multiple injuries, including a broken leg.“He hit me really hard at a really high rate of speed,” she recalled while speaking to ABC13 Houston.Following the collision, her vehicle was towed to a storage facility that had a contract with HPD. Ezike said an officer at the scene told her that the car was being taken there for investigative purposes.City rejects compensation claim despite officer being suspendedAfter the accident, Ezike approached the city's legal department seeking compensation for her medical expenses and the damage to her car. However, her claim was rejected.The decision came despite internal HPD disciplinary records reportedly showing that the officer involved had been suspended for one day for failing to use caution in connection with the crash.Ezike questioned why the city would not accept responsibility for the accident.“If I hit one of them, especially from behind, I clearly would be responsible. So, they're telling me they're not responsible due to whatever, you know, they're the government or whatever else,” she told ABC13 Houston.She said she found the city's explanation difficult to accept, particularly because the department's own records documented disciplinary action against the officer.Car declared abandoned and sold at auction for $10The dispute took a more troubling turn when Ezike discovered that her vehicle had been classified as abandoned at the storage facility and sold through an HPD vehicle auction for just $10.The sale happened less than two months after the crash, in accordance with the department's policy for auctioning vehicles considered abandoned.Ezike, however, strongly disputes that description. She said she was waiting for the city to give her permission to pay the storage charges and retrieve her car. She also claimed that a city adjuster had told her the vehicle was still being used for an investigation.HPD told ABC13 Houston that Ezike had been notified that her vehicle was being considered abandoned and had been given a deadline to collect it.Records reviewed by the investigative team reportedly described the car as repairable. Ezike said she had never intended to abandon it, especially because several personal belongings were still inside.“That's all they thought my car was worth ... $10,” she said, reacting to the sale price.Among the belongings she says she lost were clothing, household items and her late mother's ashes.Why Houston denied her claim under governmental immunityWhen ABC13 Houston contacted the city for an explanation, its legal department said Ezike's claim had initially been denied under governmental immunity because the officer was responding to an emergency call.Under the Texas Tort Claims Act, governmental immunity can be waived in certain cases involving motor vehicle accidents caused by government employees acting within the scope of their duties. However, Section 101.055 provides protection for government employees responding to emergencies, subject to exceptions involving conscious indifference or reckless disregard for the safety of others.In Ezike's case, the city reportedly relied on the officer's emergency response as the basis for rejecting her claim.The crash report also included Ezike's account of what happened before the collision. She reportedly told officials that she saw the officer's emergency lights and initially thought she was being pulled over. She slowed down and attempted to move into a parking lot to make way for the officer, but he struck her car.Houston reviewing thousands of claims against police departmentEzike's experience has come under renewed attention as Houston reviews compensation claims involving its police department.The issue gained prominence after a University of Houston student's car was damaged by police gunfire in Highland Village during an incident in which officers opened fire on a suspect. Following media attention, the city revisited the student's case and provided her with a replacement vehicle.Mayor John Whitmire subsequently announced a review of previously filed claims, acknowledging that the city had apparently followed a general practice of declaring governmental immunity in such cases.ABC13 Houston's investigation found that the city had paid approximately one in every four personal injury or property damage claims filed against HPD since 2024. The investigation also found that records from the city's legal department did not provide an explanation for why individual claims had been denied.The city later informed the news outlet that its legal department was reviewing approximately 2,000 claims dating back to July 2023. Officials did not disclose how many had been examined by the time of the report and said no previously denied claims had been reversed.Woman says she has lost her independence after the accidentFor Ezike, the consequences of the crash have extended far beyond the loss of her vehicle. In the nearly two years since the incident, she says she has had to depend on public transport, Lyft and hired taxi drivers to travel around Houston.She believes her case deserves the same consideration as the University of Houston student's claim, particularly because the accident affected her ability to move around and maintain her livelihood.When asked whether her case should be included in the city's review, she said it should absolutely be reconsidered.“They tore up my car, they stopped my livelihood. Yes, of course, mine is just as important as hers,” she told ABC13 Houston.Ezike is still waiting for the city to reconsider her claim. Meanwhile, the review of thousands of cases has raised questions about how Houston evaluates complaints involving police vehicles and why some residents are denied compensation even when internal disciplinary records document an officer's failure to exercise caution.You use AI every day. Now get your AI Quotient. Take the AIQ test.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.