Are Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals still worth it? I’ve covered sales for 6+ years — here’s my take
Are Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals actually worth it? Shopping experts share tips on what to buy, what to skip and how to find genuine discounts.
Retailers started rolling out their early Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals this week, so I’m sure you’ve asked yourself: are these discounts actually worth it? I’ve covered the massive sales for over six years, and I can say with certainty that they offer some of the year’s lowest prices across categories. But it takes a little bit of work to find the absolute best deals, and you have to strategize beforehand to save the most money. To help you make a Black Friday and Cyber Monday game plan, I put together this guide filled with tips and tricks I swear by. I also talked to experts to get their advice about what to buy, what to skip, how to find the top deals and whether shopping in-person versus online makes a difference anymore. Want more from NBC Selected? Sign up for our newsletter, The Selection, and shop smarter. What are the best things to buy during Black Friday and Cyber Monday? Tech If you have electronics on your wish list — or are buying a gift for someone who does — now is your time to buy. Tech sees some of the strongest discounts during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, especially when it comes to devices like TVs, headphones and video game consoles, says Ashley Feinstein Gerstley, a shopping and savings strategist at Rakuten, an online and in-store cashback platform. As a baseline, Vipin Porwal, the founder and consumer savings expert at Smarty, an online shopping rewards app, expects at least 30 percent off in most cases, except for TVs and computers, which are usually in the 20 to 25 percent off range. Black Friday and Cyber Monday video game bundles are particularly lucrative. It’s one of the only times a year I see brands like Nintendo, Xbox and PlayStation sell their most popular console, game and digital subscription for less than each item would cost if you bought them individually. Related deals 55% off NBA 2K27 on PS545% off the Nothing Headphone (a) 202628% off the Apple AirPods Pro 3 Toys Toys is one of the most competitive categories during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, both in terms of discounts and demand. You usually get at least 30 percent off, says Porwal, and the most popular toys sell out quickly — I’m talking a couple of hours, maximum. Once you see prices drop, buy your must-haves immediately. Some of the hottest toys and collectibles to watch this season are the Beyblade X, Jellycats, KPop Demon Hunters toys, Lego Pokémon and SMART Play, NeeDohs, Pokémon Pikachu Puppetronic, Sesame Street Tickle Me Elmo Giggle Max and Toy Story 5 toys, according to Adobe. Related deals 40% off the LeapFrog My Best Pal Scout30% off the Lego Creator 3-in-1 Forest Animals: Red Fox25% off the Yoto Mini 2024 Edition Clothes and shoes Clothes and shoes typically get marked down by at least 20 to 25 percent during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, says Porwal. Many brands run sitewide sales, so their entire inventory is marked down, while department stores and big-box retailers put most of their stock on clearance to get rid of it before the new year. Related deals 42% off the Hoka Arahi 841% off the Gap 100% Cotton Softest Flannel PJ Set33% off the Beyond Yoga Spacedye Dynamic Performance Cropped Tank Small home and kitchen appliances Almost every small home and kitchen appliance you can think of gets discounted during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, including that Vitamix blender or Dyson vacuum you’re dreaming about. In addition to items you use year-round, keep an eye on seasonal appliances, like space heaters and snow blowers, as well as tableware, home decor and other essentials you’ll need to host guests during the holidays, says Gerstley. Related deals 44% off the Roborock Q7 M5+ Robot Vacuum and Mop44% off the Shark Vertex Lift-Away Upright Vacuum35% off the De’Longhi Classic Signature Espresso Machine Subscriptions, experiences and activities Don’t forget to think beyond tangible products during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, says Mackenzie Shand, executive editor at RetailMeNot, a digital coupon, promo code and cashback platform. There are lots of deals on subscriptions, experiences and activities, too. “Many streaming services host Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales, which can lower the cost of your entertainment bill for the entire year,” she says. “Meanwhile, if you have travel plans coming up, be on the lookout for deals on things like passes to zoos, aquariums and other recreation-type places in your area.” Fitness classes, gym memberships, beauty appointments, educational platforms and event tickets also often drop in price. Additionally, while Travel Tuesday, on December 1 this year, is a dedicated day for travel deals, you’ll start seeing offers well before then. Hotels, resorts, tour groups, rental home and car booking companies, cruise lines and flight booking platforms are starting to roll out their sales now, making it the ideal time to plan a trip. You’ll see travel essentials on sale, too, like suitcases, toiletry bags and packing cubes. Related deals Get 50% off an annual subscription to The Sculpt SocietyGet 30% off or more on select Expedia vacation packages through Dec. 3Get any monthly Paramount+ plan for $2.99 per month for your first two months through Nov. 30 Gift cards and sets Because retailers know Black Friday and Cyber Monday are prime times for holiday shopping, many discount gift cards for literally everything: stores across categories, restaurants, movie theatres, spas, streaming services, food delivery platforms, and more. “As long as you plan to gift or use this gift card, you are basically getting free money from these deals,” says Shand. There are also strong discounts on gift sets, like those that bundle beauty products, gourmet food and beverages, travel essentials and accessories. You buy these sets, wrap them and give them to your recipient rather than having to curate a selection yourself. Related deals Get a $100 DoorDash gift card for $85Get a $50 $50 Aéropostale gift card for $40Get a Giftory AMC Movie Night Gift Card for 24% off What products should you avoid buying during Black Friday and Cyber Monday? No category is totally off limits during Black Friday and Cyber Monday — if you do the work, you can find a worthwhile deal on almost anything since the majority of retailers participate in the biggest shopping events of the year. But if you’re trying to narrow down your list, here’s what experts recommend waiting on and when to buy it instead: Winter clothes and shoes: wait until end-of-season clearance sales in January and FebruaryMattresses, furniture and major home and kitchen appliances: wait until three-day holiday weekend sales like Presidents’ DayBed and bath linens, like sheets and towels: wait until “white sales” in January and three-day holiday weekend sales like Presidents’ DayFitness equipment: wait until New Year’s sales in JanuaryHoliday decor: wait until after the holiday season to refresh your collection and save it for next year Are Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals worse than last year? No, Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals aren’t worse than last year, but they’re not dramatically better either, says Claudia Townsend, a consumer behavior researcher and expert and marketing professor at the University of Miami. “Prices have risen, while discount percentages are likely to remain roughly the same as last year,” she says. “This means that a 25 percent discount, for example, will yield a higher final price if the item’s starting price is higher than it was a year ago.” That said, Black Friday and Cyber Monday are still the biggest, highest-revenue days for retail of the year. Retailers want to draw customers in with deals, so most save their lowest prices for late November. But a discount isn’t a compelling enough reason alone for shoppers to spend anymore, says Shand — they’re being much more thoughtful about scoping out real deals to get the best overall value, not just the lowest price. How do you find the best Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals? 1. Make a shopping list and set a budget “The most common mistake is allowing in-the-moment sales and marketing cues define one’s shopping list,” says Townsend. “That’s how people end up “saving” 40 percent on items they never intended to buy. I recommend that consumers create a list with a budget and a target price for each item, and commit to purchasing only when a deal reaches that price.” Some retailers let you make shopping lists in their apps or on their websites and, along with certain cashback extensions, let you set up notifications when items’ prices drop so you can start evaluating immediately. That means you don’t have to do any browsing that might lead to impulse purchases — you stay zeroed in on your list the entire time. 2. Track prices Free tools like CamelCamelCamel, Keepa and Honey show you a product’s price history, as do built-in features on some retailers’ websites. Use them to determine whether an item dropped in price from a steady baseline, making it a legitimate deal, or if it’s marked down from an inflated baseline. Be sure to also use price-tracking tools to figure out what a specific product cost during Black Friday and Cyber Monday last year. That serves as a great comparison point, especially for early deals: If a product’s price dropped more during last year’s Black Friday to Cyber Monday period than the two weeks before it, you can expect a brand to follow the same pattern this year, giving you an idea about when you should finally add to cart and check out. Overall, “if the deal price matches or beats the item’s lowest price over the past year, it’s likely a good deal,” says Townsend. 3. Compare prices across retailers Before checking out, compare the price of a specific product across multiple retailers to make sure you’re getting the absolute lowest offer, says Shand. Look beyond the actual discount, too. Factor in shipping fees, extra perks like free installation and where you get the most cash back, for example. 4. Stack your savings The discount itself is your starting point. Can you bring down the price even more by signing up for email or SMS lists and getting an extra promo code; using a cashback extension; becoming a free loyalty member and earning rewards as you shop; or paying with a credit card that lets you earn points or cash back? 5. Research price matching policies If there’s a product at the top of your or your loved one’s wish list, get it as soon as it goes on sale, so long as the retailer you’re shopping at has a price-matching policy. “If a retailer will refund the difference should the price drop more, there’s little downside to buying,” says Townsend. 6. Start shopping early Retailers stretch Black Friday and Cyber Monday out across the entire month of November, so there’s no reason to wait to buy a product if you do everything you can to make sure it’s a good deal now. In fact, because so many customers are vying for the same products, and retailers limit quantities of certain products, shopping early might be the only way to get an item in the exact color, size and style you want. “Sometimes, finding the product you actually want in stock is the deal,” says Shand. “A great deal doesn’t do you much good if the product is gone.” Meet our shopping experts Claudia Townsend is a consumer behavior researcher and expert and marketing professor at the University of Miami.Ashley Feinstein Gerstley is a shopping and savings strategist at Rakuten, an online and in-store cashback platform.Mackenzie Shand is the executive editor at RetailMeNot, a digital coupon, promo code and cashback platform.Vipin Porwal is the founder and consumer savings expert at Smarty, an online shopping rewards app. Why trust NBC Selected? I’m a reporter at NBC Selected who has covered deals and sales for over six years. I write about the best overall discounts during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, as well as chart the history of both sales and what to buy versus skip. I regularly appear in related NBC News NOW and TODAY Show segments, too. To write this article, I interviewed four experts about Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Catch up on NBC Selected’s in-depth coverage of tech and tools, wellness and more, and follow us on Facebook, Instagram, X and TikTok to stay up to date.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.