Skip to content
Gigantum.net
World

A Canadian buyer found water rising through his basement floor two days after taking possession of a house; a judge ruled the seller had failed to disclose earlier water infiltration and awarded him C$129,595

A homeowner in North Bay, Ontario, has won judgment of CAD 129,595.75 against the seller of a house advertised as being in move-in condition.

· 1,268 words

A homeowner in North Bay, Ontario, has won judgment of CAD 129,595.75 against the seller of a house advertised as being in move-in condition. According to the judgment in Austin v. MacFarlane, 2026 ONSC 463, Dale Austin bought the property from Lynn MacFarlane in May 2019. On 3 May, water came up through the basement flooring where a piano rested. A contractor later found significant mould and numerous foundation cracks. The judge found that water infiltration existed before May 2019 and that MacFarlane was, at best, wilfully blind or reckless as to it. Judgment was entered for negligent misrepresentation and general damages.What defects did the homeowner discover after buying the houseThe judgment records that Austin took possession on 1 May 2019. On 3 May, movers brought the piano into the basement rec room, and water came up through the flooring wherever the piano rested. According to the judgment, this was the first time Austin noticed any water issue, and he called his real estate agent straight away. He paid the movers C$800.00 to dig out the northwest corner of the house and fix a crack with a combination of tar, Blueskin, spray foam and silicone. Over the following days, he met contractor Josef Falk, who carried out an initial assessment of the property and the repairs required.The court heard that Falk, who specialised in basement repairs, first visited the property in May 2019. According to the judgment, he saw a large crack in the foundation on the north side, near the east corner, which extended into the ground and was wide enough near the top for his fingers to fit into. After removing drywall in the affected areas of the rec room and laundry room, he observed significant mould, water-damaged drywall and numerous cracks in the foundation. The judgment records that he also noted that a door or large window had been closed at some earlier time, and he believed that work was not done to code. He testified that the windows were pushed in significantly, which he concluded was due to the way the deck was built and attached to the house.Some of the drywall he removed carried manufacturer's date stamps from 2015 and 2017, and he found six or seven such pieces along the north wall of the rec room and laundry room. He also observed newer studs alongside older ones, drywall fixed with both screws and nails, two types of insulation, and a vapour barrier that had been cut and resealed with tuck tape.What did the engineer find in the home's foundationAccording to the judgment, structural engineer Eugene Longstreet, hired by Falk in May 2019, provided a report in December 2019. He observed vertical and horizontal cracks in the foundation, a place where the block wall was pushed in by approximately two inches, and a location where an old doorway appeared to have been filled in. The judgment states that he also saw that the hole left by a deck pier was three feet, six inches deep, and he testified that the minimum frost depth for construction in North Bay is four feet. The repair work ran from May to November 2019. It involved removing the deck, excavating the north side of the house, jacking the house, replacing cement blocks along the northeast and northwest sides, and demolishing the drywall, vapour barrier and insulation in the rec room and laundry room. Mould was found during construction, and a temporary exhaust hose was installed to remove bad air.The judgment records that Lynn MacFarlane testified that she bought the house in the fall of 2010 and lived there with her daughter until the end of April 2019. She denied having significant water infiltration in the basement and denied being aware of any cracks in the foundation. She told the court that in 2017 her father filled a hole she described as smaller than a dime in the crawl space and replaced a piece of drywall in the rec room, about 3 feet by 3 to 4 feet, to repair furniture damage. Her father, Dean MacFarlane, testified to repairing a pin-sized hole in the foundation at the front of the house and to cutting out a section of drywall about 3 feet high, plus a second piece about 16 inches square.According to the judgment, the judge found that the drywall repairs went beyond the small area the defendant acknowledged, relying on Falk's evidence about the dates on the drywall, the inconsistencies in the insulation and the studs. The judge found that water infiltration existed before May 2019, rejected the defendant's evidence that she had only touched up baseboards after her dog chewed them, and found that she was, at best, wilfully blind or reckless as to the water infiltration. The judge also found that Dean MacFarlane was mistaken or dishonest about the extent of his work.Why did the court award the buyer C$129,595On the representations, the judgment records that the MLS listing described the property as a "very well maintained home in a great neighbourhood", and also as economical to operate and in move-in condition. The MLS data entry form was initialled on each page by the defendant and signed and dated 4 January 2019. According to the judgment, the Warranties and Bill of Sale, signed on 30 April 2019, stated that no damage had occurred to the property since it was inspected by the purchaser and that the warranties would survive closing. Applying the five-part test for negligent misrepresentation from Queen v. Cognos, the court found a duty of care, an untrue, inaccurate or misleading representation, negligence, reasonable reliance and resulting damage. An intention to deceive is not required. The home inspection report was not relied on for the truth of its contents because Grasser did not testify, and the judgment states that latent defects are a limitation of a home inspection report.The court awarded the claimed repair costs of CAD 119,595.75. The judgment lists them as a receipt from Robert V. Smith for CAD 800.00, an application for a building permit for CAD 400.00, and Dale’s Construction invoices of CAD 30,000.00, CAD 25,000.00, CAD 56,728.75 and CAD 6,667.00. The judge found that Austin had met his duty to mitigate, noting that he acted quickly to stop the water infiltration from worsening, repaired only the damaged portions of the foundation, replaced the deck with standard materials and stayed in the house during construction to avoid relocation costs. Austin received CAD 15,594.88 from his insurer for interior basement repairs, but both parties agreed that the damage award is not reduced by that amount under the private insurance exception. Of the CAD 100,000 sought for loss of enjoyment, inconvenience and mental stress, the court awarded CAD 10,000, stating that there was no medical or other therapeutic evidence quantifying the effect on Austin and that damages could not be awarded for the impact on his mother because she was not a party to the action. The court awarded no punitive damages, finding that the case did not involve facts so abhorrent as to warrant such an award. Judgment was entered for CAD 129,595.75 for negligent misrepresentation and general damages, with prejudgment and post-judgment interest under the Courts of Justice Act. Austin was entitled to costs, and if the parties could not agree, written submissions limited to three typewritten pages were due from the plaintiff within 30 days and from the defendant within 14 days of receiving the plaintiff’s submissions. The judgment also notes that Austin had received CAD 10,000.00 in settlement from the home inspector, Brad Grasser.You use AI every day. Now get your AI Quotient. Take the AIQ test.

Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.

Friday, November 20, 2026

© 2026 Gigantum.net. Content gathered automatically from external sources; rights to each text belong to whoever originally published it.