Skip to content
Gigantum.net
World

Impeach Hegseth? Not when Democrats don’t show up

Had the Democrats shown up and voted with their colleagues, they would have had the numbers to defeat the procedural move to table the measure.

· 857 words· updated November 17, 2026 at 12:04 PM
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth attends an event to mark Veterans Day at Arlington National Cemetery in Arlington, Va., Nov. 11, 2026.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth attends an event to mark Veterans Day at Arlington National Cemetery in Arlington, Va., Nov. 11, 2026.

Last week, in a bizarre twist of fate, it was the absence of 11 Democratic lawmakers that spared Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth a devastating rebuke and possible ouster after an election that expressed voter discontent about the Iran war.

The turn of events was surprising as Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.), soon to be Speaker of the House of Representatives, had just told ABC that an impeachment of Hegseth was a “hard yes,” as a bipartisan coalition of congressmen tried to set the table for Hegseth’s ouster.

Had the Democrats shown up and voted with their colleagues, they would have had the numbers to defeat the procedural move to table the measure, forcing an early House vote on impeachment. No Defense secretary in history has been the subject of as much scorn as Hegseth. And there is much ado in the to do.

Writers across the political spectrum have scorned his conduct with a heavy bill of particulars. This ranges from waging unauthorized war against Iran and a lack of preparedness following Iranian attacks on U.S. supply hubs in the Persian Gulf to lethal U.S. military strikes on suspected drug-smuggling vessels in Latin America. Those extrajudicial killings, which lack valid legal justification, included secondary strikes to kill survivors clinging to wreckage after an initial attack.

There’s also the removal of top-ranking military officers and the blocking of senior promotions over perceived adherence to diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. Finally, there’s retaliation against political critics such as Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) and a lack of transparency in withholding Pentagon press briefings for six months , evading public accountability for failures in the Iranian war effort.

Since it was unlikely that President Trump would fire Hegseth even under such a formidable barrage of pressure, the obvious remedy would be impeachment. Leading the charge was Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.), who authored the House resolution listing eight separate charges against Hegseth, largely mirroring the media criticism. Massie has long been a staunch critic of Hegseth.

The Republican-led House won, 211 to 204 , on a procedural motion to refer the impeachment back to the House Judiciary Committee, where it could remain indefinitely. The procedural move killed the impeachment drive for the duration of the current term, ending Jan. 3, 2027, when Democrats will take control of Congress.

The action indefinitely delayed the vote on whether to impeach Hegseth on those charges , including violating the Constitution to wage war in Iran and Yemen without congressional authorization, flouting laws to mitigate civilian casualties and abusing his power by retaliating against a senator for public statements.

Democratic politicians and progressive commentators have expressed outrage that poor attendance from Democrats affected the outcome of the vote.

Some pundits pointed the finger at Jeffries, accusing him of failing to exert sufficient pressure on party members to defeat the measure. Jeffries has said he will consult members about another possible bid to impeach Hegseth next year. “ We’ll have that conversation ,” Jeffries said, calling Hegseth “the most unqualified secretary of defense in American history.” He stopped, however, at calling for Hegseth’s impeachment.

If convicted after impeachment, Hegseth would be immediately removed from office. But, for conviction, the Constitution requires at least a two-thirds concurring vote in the Senate. That means Senate Democrats, even with their incoming majority in the chamber next year, would likely need about a dozen Republicans to join them to secure Hegseth’s removal.

Trump said the vote was an “ exoneration ” of Hegseth. Hardly. The outcome gave him an unexpected reprieve, but only for a while. Democrats could still move to impeach him next year when they assume power.

Hegseth’s standing in the administration was further thrown into question following sweeping Republican losses in the midterm elections. It had not been clear whether Republican lawmakers, including several who were unexpectedly defeated or won reelection far more narrowly than they anticipated, would rally to support him. It was no accident that seven Republicans didn’t show up for the vote either. In the end, though, more Democrats than Republicans missed the vote.

The vote came hours after Hegseth defiantly defended himself at a Pentagon news briefing, equating the criticisms of him to critiques of American troops. “I stand behind every one of these operations,” he said of the military actions cited in the articles as unlawful conduct. “I was proud to execute them, and I would do it again tomorrow.”

Some Republicans who had expressed dissatisfaction with Hegseth’s performance ultimately concluded that impeachment was not the appropriate remedy, noting that Hegseth served at the pleasure of the president, and that any decision to fire him rested with Trump.

Others had privately raised concerns that the articles of impeachment, which include wide-ranging allegations of misconduct when overseeing military operations, only reflected policy disputes within the Pentagon.

Vice President Vance made a spirited defense of Hegseth, saying that the impeachment effort was nothing more than political theater.

“Has Pete Hegseth committed impeachable crimes?” asked Vance . “The question is absurd and the answer is: obviously not.”

James D. Zirin is a former federal prosecutor in the Southern District of New York and a published legal analyst.

Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

© 2026 Gigantum.net. Content gathered automatically from external sources; rights to each text belong to whoever originally published it.