Skip to content
Gigantum.net
World

A 62-year-old son fought his siblings for their parents’ £600,000 home, claiming he was promised the entire inheritance; a judge rejected his account, ordered him to leave within 28 days and pay £265,000

A family home worth around £600,000 became the centre of a prolonged inheritance dispute after one of three siblings attempted to secure the property for

· 1,165 words

A family home worth around £600,000 became the centre of a prolonged inheritance dispute after one of three siblings attempted to secure the property for himself. Robert Chung, 62, argued that his parents had intended him to receive the house because he had returned to live with them and claimed to have cared for them in their later years. His brother and sister, however, painted a different picture, accusing him of behaving like a 'parasite' by relying on their mother to look after him rather than providing care in return. They challenged his account of the family's arrangements and disputed his claim to the entire inheritance. As reported by The Independent, the dispute eventually reached Central London County Court, where a judge rejected his claims, directed him to leave the property and ordered him to pay £265,000 in costs and occupation-related charges.How the £600,000 family home became the centre of an inheritance disputeRobert's parents, Victor and Irene Chung, raised their three children in a detached, three-bedroom house in Mulberry Way, South Woodford. The property later became the most valuable part of their estate. While Robert's siblings, Marina Bennett and Richard Chung, moved away and established professional careers, he remained closely connected to the family home.Robert had previously moved out to Berkshire but returned in 1990. He subsequently worked at a Job Centre and continued living with his parents. His father died in 1998, leaving his estate to Irene. When she died in 2016, she had not left a will. Under the rules governing intestacy, her estate was therefore to be divided equally among her three children.Robert disputed the arrangement. He maintained that his parents had told him he would eventually receive the house, claiming that his decision to return home had been connected to providing support as they grew older. His siblings rejected this version of events, arguing that there was no reliable evidence of any agreement that would entitle him to the entire property.Robert claimed his parents promised him the entire family homeDuring the proceedings, Robert told the court that his father had assured him he would inherit the family home. He also alleged that Victor had said Irene could return to Finland, where she was originally from, without receiving any part of his estate. Robert claimed that his mother repeated the promise after her husband's death, giving him further reason to believe the property would eventually belong to him.His siblings disputed these assertions. Their legal representative, Faisel Sadiq, argued that the parents had not made any such commitment and that Robert's attempt to obtain the entire property would leave little of the inheritance for Marina and Richard.The judge also considered the documentary evidence, including Victor's final will, which left his estate to Irene. There was no reference to the alleged arrangement concerning the house or to any intention to exclude his wife from the inheritance. Recorder Lawrence McDonald found Robert's account unreliable. He said several parts of his evidence were inconsistent with other material presented during the case and that some of his claims had emerged only when he was questioned in court.The judge rejected the suggestion that Victor had intended to leave his wife without financial provision after their decades-long marriage. He concluded that Robert had lied about the alleged promises made by both parents.Siblings challenged his claims of caring for their elderly motherThe disagreement was not limited to who should inherit the property. A significant part of the hearing concerned Robert's assertion that he had returned to the family home to look after his father and later supported his mother as she grew older. His siblings offered a different account of everyday life in the house. Marina, a senior accountant who had worked in the US and Canada, told the court that she was shocked by the condition of her mother and the property when she visited in 2016. She questioned how Robert could claim to have been providing care when, according to her, Irene was still responsible for much of the household work.Marina also described her brother spending long periods watching films in the living room while their mother dealt with cooking, cleaning and other domestic responsibilities. Her husband, Stephen Bennett, provided further evidence, recalling occasions when he had helped with household repairs despite Robert living at the property. Reportedly, Robert maintained that he had contributed to his parents' household and pointed to giving his mother around £50 each week towards expenses. He also referred to preparing mashed potatoes for meals as an example of his involvement.Recorder McDonald did not consider these contributions sufficient to establish that Robert had been caring for his mother. He said the evidence suggested Irene continued to manage the household, including washing, cooking and cleaning, while also helping to look after her grandchildren. The judge found that Robert had not provided the level of support he claimed, either to his mother or to his father.Judge rejected the inheritance claim and ordered him to leaveIn dismissing Robert's case, the judge said his allegations about the promises made by his parents were unsupported by the available records. He was particularly critical of the suggestion that Victor had intended to send Irene back to Finland without any financial provision. The court also considered the consequences of allowing Robert to inherit the entire property. Such an outcome would have left no significant assets available for distribution between his siblings, despite the absence of evidence that their mother had intended to favour one child over the others.The ruling required Robert to vacate the South Woodford property within 28 days and remove his belongings. The court also made a financial order totalling £265,000, covering legal expenses and charges relating to his continued occupation of the house.Of that amount, £90,000 was awarded towards the legal costs incurred by his siblings and the administrator of the estate. The remaining £175,000 represented mesne profits, a legal term for compensation payable for occupying property without the right to do so, covering the period after he had been asked to leave following his mother's death.His legal battle could have consumed his share of the inheritanceThe proceedings had continued for more than eight years, leaving the administration of Irene's estate unresolved long after her death. The judge said the dispute needed to end, particularly given the time already spent dealing with the property and the competing claims. The court also heard that Robert's siblings had previously offered him a settlement that would have allowed him to receive 62.5% of the property's value. That proposal was not accepted, and the case proceeded to trial. Under the outcome, each of the three children remained entitled to one-third of the estate. However, the legal expenses and occupation-related payment could substantially reduce the value of the share Robert might otherwise have received.Disclaimer: This article is based on publicly available court reports and media coverage. The Times of India has not independently verified the claims made by the parties.You use AI every day. Now get your AI Quotient. Take the AIQ test.

Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

© 2026 Gigantum.net. Content gathered automatically from external sources; rights to each text belong to whoever originally published it.