A videographer sued a media company for republishing his video of Michael Jordan breaking up a fight; a US appeals court revived his copyright claim, ruling that the full clip could act as a substitute for the original
A US appeals court has revived part of a videographer’s copyright claim against a media company that republished his footage of Michael Jordan breaking up
A US appeals court has revived part of a videographer’s copyright claim against a media company that republished his footage of Michael Jordan breaking up a fight. In Richardson v. Townsquare Media, Inc., decided on 23 April 2026, the Second Circuit ruled that the district court incorrectly determined, at the pleading stage, that Townsquare’s use of the 42-second Jordan Video was fair. Because Townsquare republished the entire video, the court said it potentially provided consumers with a substitute work. The court vacated the ruling on screenshots, but affirmed judgment on a separate Melle Mel video, citing YouTube’s licence, and remanded.Michael Jordan video copyright case faces appeal setbackRichardson sued Townsquare, claiming that its use of his content violated his copyrights. The district court, presided over by Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, granted Townsquare judgment on the pleadings. According to the appeals court, the district court concluded that Townsquare's use of the Jordan Video was fair, that its reproduction of screenshots was de minimis and therefore not actionable, and that its embedding of a second video was permissible under a licence in YouTube's Terms of Service.On appeal, the Second Circuit reviewed the decision afresh. It stated that it "draw[s] all reasonable inferences in the plaintiff's favour" and must vacate the judgment "if there are issues of fact which if proved would [permit a verdict for the nonmoving party]". The court summarised its conclusion by saying that it disagreed "in part and agree[d] in part" with the district court. The second video was an interview Richardson had recorded with rapper Melle Mel, in which Melle Mel criticised rapper Eminem. Townsquare had embedded it in two articles. The first covered the comments themselves, and the second covered rapper 50 Cent's response defending Eminem.Second Circuit questions Townsquare's fair use of Jordan videoThe Second Circuit held that the district court "incorrectly determined, at the pleading stage, that Townsquare's use of the Jordan Video was fair". The opinion notes that fair use is usually addressed at summary judgment. It adds that, to warrant dismissal of a complaint, "the fair-use factors must point decisively in the defence's favour". The court found that the district court had erred in assessing the first, third and fourth statutory factors. On the first factor, which covers the purpose and character of the use, the court called transformativeness "a closer call" than the district court's analysis suggested. It also noted that Townsquare is a for-profit entity, and assessed the factor as "at best, neutral". On the second factor, the nature of the copyrighted work, the court agreed with the district court that it weighed in favour of fair use, though it described the factor as one of "limited import".The third and fourth factors were central to the decision. Townsquare conceded that it republished the entire video, and the court found its arguments that doing so was necessary "premature and underdeveloped at the pleading stage". The opinion states that Townsquare "could have, for example, republished the text of the post along with a portion of the video", taken a screenshot of the post, or reported on the controversy with a hyperlink. On the fourth factor, the market effect, the court wrote that "it is plausible that viewers may not need to pay Richardson to watch the Jordan Video a second time if they can see it in full on Townsquare's website". The court concluded that Townsquare's decision to republish the entire video "rendered its use of the video a plausible market substitute for the video itself". It added that discovery may yet show Townsquare's use was reasonably justified, but that this was "not apparent at this early point in the litigation".Court rules screenshots in Jordan video case may infringe copyrightOn the screenshots, the district court had applied the de minimis doctrine, reasoning that a single still frame made up a very small fraction of the original video. The Second Circuit disagreed, stating that the doctrine "has no application here, as Townsquare prominently displayed the screenshots as the backdrop to the headline in each article". The court said the doctrine applies where the copyrighted work plays a negligible or incidental role. In its words, "the copyrighted work is the very subject of the secondary work", and easy identification "was indeed Townsquare's intention". It also rejected Townsquare's argument that the observability analysis in earlier cases applies only to "visual works" and not "video works", calling that argument "meritless". The court declined to affirm on the alternative ground of fair use, noting that the district court had not ruled on that basis.The Melle Mel Video was treated differently. The court affirmed the district court on that claim, holding that it was foreclosed by YouTube's Terms of Service. The opinion states that the licence granted to other users to use content "only as enabled by a feature of the Service (such as video playback or embeds)" "unambiguously covers Townsquare's use". The court rejected Richardson's reliance on Section 12 of YouTube's API Terms, and said Townsquare's alleged failure to follow other YouTube policies did not affect the scope of the licence. In a footnote, the court noted that the licence "on its face does not appear to cover Townsquare's use of the screenshots", so its holding "applies only to Townsquare's embedding of the video". The court vacated the judgment as to the Jordan Video and the screenshots from both videos, affirmed it as to the Melle Mel Video, and remanded for further proceedings consistent with its opinion.You use AI every day. Now get your AI Quotient. Take the AIQ test.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.