Why an Alaska win by Peltola is so important to Democrats
Senate Democrats are seeking to complete what has been a historic midterm election campaign with one final win in Alaska, where Democrat Mary Peltola is on track to oust Sen. Dan Sullivan (R) as ballots trickle in. A Democratic victory in Alaska would represent the party’s ninth midterm Senate flip and make for a 56-seat majority in…
Senate Democrats are seeking to complete what has been a historic midterm election campaign with one final win in Alaska, where Democrat Mary Peltola is on track to oust Sen. Dan Sullivan (R) as ballots trickle in.
A Democratic victory in Alaska would represent the party’s ninth midterm Senate flip and make for a 56-seat majority in the upper chamber.
That’s four seats short of a filibuster-proof majority, but the numbers reinforce Democrats’ leverage to bypass the procedure if they are able to recruit just a few GOP votes for legislation.
Just as importantly, a win in Alaska would make it that much more difficult for Republicans to win back the Senate majority in 2028.
Peltola would also be the latest Democrat elected to a six-year term in what is generally seen as a red state, joining other Democratic winners, such as Sens.-elect Annie Andrews (S.C.), James Talarico (Texas), Josh Turek (Iowa), Adam Hamilton (Kan.) and, after last week’s upset, Scott Colom (Miss.).
“I think the victory in Alaska just kind of puts the cherry on top that says this is going to be an interesting couple years,” said Steve Jarding, a Democratic strategist and former senior aide to the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC).
The Last Frontier is now the last Senate race on the midterm table, and Peltola is poised to narrowly prevail in a state that Trump won by 13 percentage points in the 2024 presidential race. As of noon EST Tuesday, she was 4 points ahead of Sullivan with 93 percent of the vote counted by Decision Desk HQ (DDHQ).
Alaska runs on ranked choice voting, and voting will kick into another round of tabulation if no candidate gets more than 50 percent of first-choice votes. But the sprawling rural state lets properly postmarked absentee ballots come in until Wednesday, drawing out the suspense. Alaska’s Division of Elections has set Nov. 25 as the target date for certification.
Peltola hovered just below the 50 percent threshold — 48.98 percent of the vote — as of Tuesday. Her team said over the weekend that the latest ballot drops had locked in her win.
“There is no mathematical path for Sullivan to win this race,” her campaign said in a release.
Sullivan’s camp, meanwhile, said Monday it would “not be commenting on individual ballot updates or outside projections” and would have more to say later this week.
Republicans have argued that a candidate with the same name as the incumbent has confused voters — with Trump last week calling the race “rigged.” A federal judge earlier this month threw out a lawsuit from the Trump administration seeking to block the certification of the election if the incumbent were to lose.
“No state has benefitted more from Republican leadership than Alaska, so Democrats deceived voters to tip the scale and rig this race. Mary Peltola let Democrats attack Alaska incessantly the last time she was in office, and she’ll do the same if she gets to the Senate,” National Republican Senatorial Committee national press secretary Bernadette Breslin said in a statement, referencing The New York Times reporting that Peltola recruited a candidate to pull votes from the incumbent. The Democrat has disputed the reporting.
As of Tuesday afternoon, votes tallied by DDHQ for Peltola exceeded those of both Sullivans combined.
A 56-seat majority in the Senate would be the biggest for a party since the 2008 blue wave , when Democrats at one point held 60 seats, including independents who caucused with the party. But a win for Peltola, strategists said, would do more than bump up the party’s numbers.
“Winning in a place you know that they weren’t supposed to win … I think it sends a signal, and we’re seeing it play out now,” said Jarding, calling the freshman class on Capitol Hill “a new breed of legislator in the Democratic Party, both in the House and Senate, that do not adhere to the status quo.”
Jarding also suggested the newly elected Democrats in battleground and Republican-leaning states may be the ones to chart out the party’s course in the Senate over the next two years.
Talarico’s win marked the first Texas Democratic Senate win in decades, and it came with a sweep of other top statewide offices. In Kansas, Hamilton is the first Democrat elected to the Senate in nearly a century.
Democrats also recaptured Mississippi for the first time in decades after days of suspense in a tight race, with Colom winning by less than a percentage point in a red stronghold that Trump won by around 23 points in 2024.
The incoming Democrats hail from “very key states” in the Midwest, the South and beyond and could also reshape the broader political map for the party heading into 2028, said Basil Smikle, a Columbia University professor and Democratic strategist.
Democrats could use their winning states as “policy incubators” to help build the party’s case for “why Democrats should take over in 2028,” Smikle said, while the numbers game makes it harder for Republicans to regain control of the Senate in the next cycle.
Jarding also suggested the results of the November midterms could send a signal to Republicans to play ball with Democrats, giving the party a few additional players to work with on key priorities.
“To have that ninth [seat flip] is just so critical because I think it doesn’t just give the Democrats an extra vote; it puts more pressure on the Republicans, particularly the 2028 Republicans, to say, ‘Are we going to just go against everything that they do because we normally do that or because we’re fearful of Donald Trump or … are we going to look over our shoulder and say if we give in to Trump they’re coming for us?’” the former top DSCC strategist said.
Democrats would still boast a 55-seat majority even if Alaska bucks the forecasts and remains in GOP hands — but strategists say a 56th seat could be instrumental in shaping party politics through the next several cycles.
“The numbers do matter: 55, 56. The extent of the majority matters because that shows the level of strength they’ll have in trying to constrain Trump, in that because the voters really do want someone that’s going to take on the fight,” Smikle said.
“The more comfortable majority they have, the less they have to worry about broader blowback and reining in the Republican members. The more of a majority they have, the more comfortably they can engage the House on so many of these issues, get some passed, maybe create a smooth landing for others.”
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.