DOJ tells court Kennedy Center will ‘be taken down’ if renovations are blocked

In an unusually pugnacious filing, Justice Department lawyers warned that stopping President Trump's renovation and renaming push could doom the national memorial and floated replacing it with a riverside amphitheater.

The Trump administration has told a federal court that the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts may have to be demolished if a judge won't let the president close it for a years-long renovation and add his name to the building.

The warning arrived in a Justice Department filing submitted Monday, the court-ordered deadline for the administration to answer an emergency motion from a Democratic member of the center's own board. Written by Brantley Mayers, a senior attorney in the DOJ's Civil Division, it argues the "decrepit" center is locked in a financial and structural "death spiral" that only Trump can reverse.

"Without those efforts, the Center will deteriorate further into an unsafe, decrepit structure that will be required to be taken down," the filing says, with a later decision on "what to build on the site, such as a large outdoor amphitheater overlooking the Potomac River that has been proposed, by some, for many years." Such a replacement, the department allowed, would "fail to adequately honor President John F. Kennedy," though it would be "simpler and more economical to build, operate, and maintain."

The filing does not read like a routine government brief. As ABC7 reported , it "at times reads like a post from Trump's social media platform." An attorney for the Democratic congresswoman challenging the plan went further, calling the document "legally baseless" and saying it "reads like it was written personally by Donald Trump."

Strip away the demolition talk, and this is a separation-of-powers dispute over who controls a memorial that Congress created. Rep. Joyce Beatty of Ohio, an ex-officio board member, asked the court last week, the Associated Press reported , to stop the board from returning Trump's name to the facade and from renaming the surrounding grounds "President Donald J. Trump Plaza." She sued the administration in December , after the board first renamed the complex for Trump, on the argument that only Congress can rename a memorial it established.

A judge has already sided with her once. U.S. District Judge Christopher R. Cooper, an Obama appointee, ruled in May that the board lacked the authority to rename the center, writing that "Congress gave the Kennedy Center its name, and only Congress can change it." Trump's name came off the building in June, and a tarp has covered the spot ever since. Cooper is set to hear Beatty's latest motion Thursday.

The administration's case rests on a blunt premise: the tributes are what keep the checks coming. The filing calls the board-approved honors "crucial" to fundraising and warns that an order "blocking the Board from appropriately recognizing President Trump will cause donors to flee, financial contributions to dry up, and structural rehabilitation to stop." It says Trump has already secured $258 million from Congress for capital work and lined up a new donor base, and it leans on his real-estate background, calling him uniquely qualified to run the project. Putting his name back, the department adds, doesn't defy Cooper's order because the building's legal name stays the same, and acknowledging major donors is "ubiquitous" at comparable venues.

Beatty isn't buying it. She voted against the board's resolution and has called the renewed push "a transparent effort to circumvent" the court. Her attorneys accused the center of "playing chicken with the Court," and in a separate filing argued that shuttering the venue for two years is really about burying the "embarrassing fact" that renaming it for Trump has been a financial flop, which they called a breach of fiduciary duty. The Kennedy Center rejects that framing. A spokeswoman said the board is confident the court will uphold both the name change and the renovations, which it insists are overdue, and has blamed the center's finances on prior leadership.

How a renaming became a demolition threat

Trump moved on the Kennedy Center almost as soon as he took office, ousting its leadership, installing a board that named him chairman, and briefly rebranding the institution around his own name before the court intervened. He is appealing that loss . On Aug. 13, the board, stacked with his allies, voted (20-3, by one account) to inscribe "Restored and Renovated by President Donald J. Trump" on the facade, to add an "Endowed by the Trump Kennedy Center Fund" line if a $100 million endowment target is met, to rename the grounds for him, and to close most of the complex for two years. The center has said it won't engrave the name before Sept. 8 while the legal arguments unfold. A separate coalition of preservation and architecture groups sued back in March to block the renovation itself, arguing it never got the congressional sign-off the law requires.

For all the talk of stage lifts and rigging, the filing quietly reframes a maintenance quarrel as something far larger: a test of whether a president can rename, remake, or even raze a congressionally created national memorial over the objection of the branch that built it. The administration casts demolition as the tragic price of losing. Beatty casts the entire project as a monument to one man's vanity. On Thursday, the judge who has already ruled once gets to decide which version the law will accept.

7 Outdated Habits People Over 60 Should Leave Behind for a Healthier, Happier Life

"My Doctor Clipped My Wings": Dolly Parton Shares Health Update After Missing Dollywood Celebration

Before his death, James Van Der Beek overlooked an early colorectal cancer symptom. Here are 12 subtle signs

The post DOJ tells court Kennedy Center will 'be taken down' if renovations are blocked appeared first on FODMAP Everyday .