Judge drops Max Miller lawsuit against ex-wife, concluding abuse allegation ‘substantially true’
An Ohio judge dismissed Rep. Max Miller’s (R-Ohio) defamation lawsuit against his ex-wife Emily Moreno on Monday, after finding the outgoing lawmaker failed to provide credible evidence that Moreno leaked abuse allegations to the media. Cuyahoga County Judge Joy Kennedy also found that an allegation that Miller doused Moreno with boiling hot water during a…
An Ohio judge dismissed Rep. Max Miller’s (R-Ohio) defamation lawsuit against his ex-wife Emily Moreno on Monday, after finding the outgoing lawmaker failed to provide credible evidence that Moreno leaked abuse allegations to the media.
Cuyahoga County Judge Joy Kennedy also found that an allegation that Miller doused Moreno with boiling hot water during a June 2024 argument was “substantially true,” citing an audio recording of the pair discussing the incident.
“It is Plaintiffs burden to support his claims with credible, admissible evidence,” Kennedy wrote in a 15-page order . “Plaintiff has not shown that the statement about dousing Defendant Moreno with boiling hot water are false.”
Miller sued Moreno in May, claiming she worked with a Cleveland-based law firm to issue statements to national media outlets accusing him of physical abuse to hurt his reelection campaign and influence an ongoing custody dispute. The couple filed for divorce in August 2024 and has one daughter.
The complaint specifically referred to an article from the Daily Mail containing details about the hot water incident, which Miller recounts differently.
The judge found the Ohio Republican had not produced credible evidence showing that Moreno was one of the anonymous sources cited in the article or that she “caused the article to be published.”
“For the foregoing reasons, construing the evidence in the light most favorable to Plaintiff, the Court finds that there is no credible evidence in support of Plaintiffs claims against Defendant Moreno,” the judge concluded.
Kennedy also determined that Miller had not proved his ex-wife acted with “actual malice,” the legal defamation standard for public figures. He was ordered to pay roughly $76,000 in attorneys’ fees and costs.
Moreno, the daughter of Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio), moved to dismiss the lawsuit under Ohio’s anti-SLAPP law, which is designed to deter individuals from using the legal process to intimidate or chill speech.
“Congressman Miller tried to use the courts as a weapon to intimidate his ex-wife and silence speech on a matter of vital public concern — allegations about an elected official’s abusive behavior,” Subodh Chandra, Emily Moreno’s lead attorney, said in a statement.
“Judge Kennedy’s thorough opinion confirms what the evidence showed from day one: Ms. Moreno did not leak the story, Congressman Miller admitted on a recording to his conduct, and he had zero credible evidence to support his lawsuit,” Chandra added.
An attorney for Miller did not immediately return The Hill’s request for comment.
Miller faced intense political pressure to resign after reports of domestic abuse surfaced in July, including that he held a gun to Moreno’s head and broke their daughter’s collarbone during their marriage. He has denied the allegations.
The lawmaker pressed ahead with his reelection campaign despite the scandal, ultimately losing to Democrat Brian Poindexter by more than 9 percentage points.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.