Skip to content
Gigantum.net
Politics

Conservatives look to protect Electoral College from Democrats

A wave of Democratic victories in state houses around the country, not to mention Congress, has put new momentum behind a long-sought Democratic effort to reshape how presidential elections are won. Many Democrats have, for years, been eager to revamp presidential elections by scrapping the Electoral College, especially after the contests of 2000 and 2016…

· 1,646 words· updated November 17, 2026 at 08:03 AM
Voting stickers are displayed on Election Day in Missoula, Mont., Tuesday, Nov. 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Tommy Martino)
Voting stickers are displayed on Election Day in Missoula, Mont., Tuesday, Nov. 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Tommy Martino)

A wave of Democratic victories in state houses around the country, not to mention Congress, has put new momentum behind a long-sought Democratic effort to reshape how presidential elections are won.

Many Democrats have, for years, been eager to revamp presidential elections by scrapping the Electoral College, especially after the contests of 2000 and 2016 put Republican presidents in power even as the Democratic candidate won the popular vote. Any such effort is certain to face legal challenges – but the renewed interest is already putting conservatives on high alert.

Supporters of the overhaul are pushing for more states to enact the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, an agreement committing a state to award its electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote, even if state voters choose otherwise. Nineteen jurisdictions including D.C. have enacted the compact into law, and six other states have passed it in legislative chambers.

The reformers’ goal, fittingly, is to get enough states to codify the compact to account for 270 Electoral College votes, meaning a presidential election would be won on the popular vote by way of the Electoral College. Several states that could bolster support just elected Democratic lawmakers who are open to the move , including reelected Gov. Josh Shapiro in Pennsylvania and Gov.-elect David Crowley in Wisconsin.

The compact must get 270 votes before it goes into effect in any state.

But conservatives, who tend to benefit from the Electoral College, have been warning against those changes for years. One argument in support of the current system is that it forces presidential candidates to pay attention to the concerns of voters in low-population states, which tend to be rural and red, rather than focusing on pure numbers by courting population centers like California and New York. Put another way: It prevents the “tyranny of the majority.”

Those hoping to trash that system maintain that voter sentiment, nationally, should take precedence over the state-weighted system, which has sent five presidents to the White House without winning the popular vote. In that sense, they say, it prevents the “tyranny of the minority.”

“Pennsylvania can still play a massive role even in the national popular vote,” Shapiro, who’s weighing a 2028 presidential bid, told “ Pod Save America ” shortly after the midterms. “And to me the most important thing is that the will of the people is heard and respected, and I think the popular vote is the way to do that.”

It also creates a more decisive victory in the margin by which candidates win: In 2024, President Trump won the Electoral College by a margin of about 16 percent. He won the popular vote by about 2.3 million votes, a margin of about 1.5 percent.

Those who back the status quo disagree, saying it was the Founders’’ intent to balance out the urban and rural votes, and that the fundamentals have not changed enough to warrant reforming the electoral system.

Katherine Bennett, an expert in the topic at the American Legislative Exchange Council, said the same rural-urban divide that the Founders warned against is present in today’s political landscape, underscoring the continued need for the Electoral College.

“If you’re tying all of the electoral votes from all of the states that enter the compact to the popular vote, what can very easily happen, and what our organization has been talking about for a long time, is that the rural areas of the country are losing their voice in the presidential election process,” Bennett said.

The mechanism is also a unique one that could call up constitutional questions. The Electoral College is written into the Constitution, requiring an amendment to change it, but constitutional amendments are very difficult to ratify. The interstate compact, opponents say, is a sneaky workaround that will likely face legal scrutiny if more states adopt it.

Hans von Spakovsky , a conservative legal scholar, wrote in a 2020 report for the Heritage Foundation that the “compact clause” in the Constitution has already been tested by the Supreme Court and would likely be called up in the case of the popular vote compact, or NPV, going further.

A handful of states agreeing to award electors one way without the consent of Congress is not how the Founders intended Electoral College change to come about, he argued, and thus the Supreme Court would probably rule against it.

“By eliminating the requirement that Congress approve a virtual constitutional amendment, the NPV would enhance the power of certain states at the expense of the national government,” von Spakovsky wrote. “Moreover, the NPV would deprive non-participating states of their right under Article V to participate in deciding whether the Twelfth Amendment, which governs the Electoral College, should be changed.”

Welcome to The Movement , a weekly newsletter looking at the influences and debates on the right in Washington. I’m Helen Huiskes, Senate reporter.

Send me tips, comments, and suggestions: hhuiskes@thehill.com

The latest target of Republican lawmakers’ investigative efforts is somewhat surprising: the former CEO of one of the world’s most valuable companies.

Jensen Huang , who resigned last week from Nvidia, is facing calls for questioning from Republicans and Democrats alike in Congress over allegations that he had multiple extramarital affairs, including one with a subordinate and one with an alleged Chinese spy.

Trump has stood by Huang, even suggesting he should be reinstated. But House and Senate Republican leaders have called for closed-door hearings with Huang to interrogate the national security implications. They’ve also demanded to hear from Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick over his handling of chip export controls .

It puts the China-hawk wing of the conservative movement squarely in the spotlight and somewhat in contrast with Trump, who has largely backed tech companies with whom he is friendly, and who has already upset Republicans by rolling out a literal red carpet for Chinese President Xi Jinping earlier this year.

Rep. John Moolenaar (R-Mich.), the chair of the House Permanent Select Committee on China, said on CNBC last week that he wants to know whether Huang shared privileged information about America’s artificial intelligence capabilities, whether China asserted influence over Nvidia’s advocacy regarding chip sales to China and whether Nvidia favored China over the U.S. in its own chip sales.

“If it becomes less of an investigation, more of damage control, that’s not going to work because people have to have confidence,” Moolenaar said.

Rep. Brian Mast (R-Fla.), chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, told reporters Thursday that Huang had agreed to testify.

Moolenaar and Mast, along with Rep. Rick Crawford (R-Ark.), the chair of the House Intelligence Committee, sent a letter on Nov. 12 summoning Huang to a closed-door, transcribed hearing in front of all three committees, threatening a subpoena.

Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.), chair of the Senate Banking Committee, is also looking into Huang, as well as Lutnick over his role in the administration’s reported soft posture toward chip sales to China, which have benefited his family financially . Lutnick has reportedly agreed to appear before the Banking Committee voluntarily.

Sen. Jim Banks (R-Ind.), who also serves on that panel, said in a Fox News interview Thursday that he wanted answers from Lutnick and Huang on how Nvidia’s pressure on lawmakers to oppose restrictions on chip exports may have benefited China. He called the news “as concerning as it gets.”

“When you’re in a war with another country, you don’t give them your best technologies. And that’s why lawmakers, for the last two years, have been pushing hard to stop our high-end computer chips from being exported to China,” Banks said.

Meanwhile, some conservative voices online are irate over the implication that Huang’s influence in the U.S. could have benefited China in the AI arms race.

“Please remember that the entire case for exporting AI chips to China rested on the say-so of the one corrupt company that stood most to benefit from the sales,” said Oren Cass, founder of conservative think tank American Compass. Cass wrote an essay last year criticizing how Huang had repeatedly defended Nvidia’s chip sales to China.

The other outstanding question from lawmakers is why, after Lutnick was reportedly sent a classified memo earlier this year outlining national security concerns about one of Huang’s affairs, Huang was not warned.

“They knew in 2024 that there was a red flag and then by mid-2025, so over a year ago, they had some concern. My questions would be, what did Commerce do about it, what did the Secretary of State do about it, was there a national security council meeting on it, what did the president do about it and why didn’t they tell Jensen Huang?” said Nikki Haley, former ambassador to the United Nations and Republican presidential candidate, in a Bloomberg interview last week. “I think we should assume everybody meant well but something terrible in the process happened.”

A Senate panel will vote Wednesday on the nomination of Heidi Overton for commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration. It’s not clear if Overton, a senior White House policy aide, has the votes to proceed, as several key Republican senators have concerns about her. More here.

The American Principles Project sent a letter to Senate Majority Leader John Thune calling for lame-duck action on several bills related to child safety online. Letter here .

Republicans on the Senate Appropriations Committee released a draft of a defense spending bill at a total of $1.1 trillion. More here .

November 18: The Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity hosts Freedom & Progress 2026, a gathering of leaders committed to expanding opportunity through free enterprise, innovation, pluralism, and individual liberty. Details here .

R.R. Reno in First Things: How to Train Your Elites

Patrick T. Brown in the National Catholic Register: Faith Returns to the Political Menu

Ivana Greco in The New York Times: Opinion: Misogyny Is Tearing the Young Right Apart

Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

© 2026 Gigantum.net. Content gathered automatically from external sources; rights to each text belong to whoever originally published it.