Anthropic’s registered trademark does not rule out passing-off claim: Lawyer
Belagavi firm says lawsuit vs US-based Anthropic can proceed as a passing-off claim without a registered trademark; court to hear reply Nov 23.
Belagavi: Belagavi-based Anthropic Softwares has argued before the Belagavi District Commercial Court that its suit against US-based AI company Anthropic is maintainable even though it does not have a registered trademark.The argument follows the defendant’s contention at the previous hearing that the suit was not maintainable without a registered trademark. The defence had also questioned the jurisdiction of the Belagavi Commercial Court.Appearing for the plaintiff on Tuesday, advocate M M Sheikh argued that the dispute concerns passing off rather than trademark infringement. While an infringement claim generally requires a registered trademark, a passing-off action can be brought even without registration, he submitted.He argued that the plaintiff was entitled to seek legal protection where the cause of action arose. He also contended that registration of a trademark does not give a company the right to exploit another business’s established goodwill or automatically protect it from a passing-off action.He submitted that Anthropic Softwares had built its reputation through years of investment and business development, and alleged that the defendant was attempting to exploit the goodwill of the Belagavi-based company.“The Anthropic Softwares company was registered in 2017 and has remained operational since then. It has invested considerable resources, time and effort to nurture this business like a child. Now, a foreign entity is attempting to destroy it. Such exploitation must be restrained,” he argued.Referring to Section 27(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, Sheikh said it preserves the right to initiate passing-off proceedings irrespective of whether a trademark is registered. He argued that Sections 28 and 29, cited by the defendant, deal with rights arising from trademark registration and infringement of registered trademarks, respectively.Countering the defendant’s contention that Anthropic India Pvt Ltd, Bengaluru, was a separate legal entity from its US-based parent, Sheikh said the Indian company was a subsidiary and that its relationship with the parent should be considered in the dispute.On jurisdiction, he referred to Sections 15 and 21 of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, arguing that intellectual property disputes, including those involving trademarks and domain names, qualify as commercial disputes under the Act.The defendant’s counsel sought time to file a brief reply to the allegations. Judge R P Gowda adjourned the matter to Nov 23.Money habits form by age 7. Is your child learning the right ones? Join the TOI Money Masterclass.
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.