This Couple Pulled $600,000 From The Stock Market When Things Got Scary. Now They're Fighting Over Who Made Them Miss The Rebound

Benzinga and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below.

A married couple, ages 45 and 43, got spooked during a steep market selloff and sold their entire $600,000 brokerage portfolio. Eight months later, stocks have climbed back, their money is still sitting in a savings account, and each spouse blames the other for pushing the sale.

The argument misses the real problem. They're not stuck because of one bad decision; they're stuck because they never had a plan for what to do when markets fell. Getting back in the right way matters more than figuring out who panicked first.

Think Your IRA Can Only Hold Stocks And Funds? Think Again. Here's What A Self-Directed IRA Can Actually Invest In.

Real Estate Investing Without Buying A House? This 6-Month Strategy Is Offering 8% APY. Here's How The Private-Market Investment Works.

What Sitting In Cash Has Likely Cost Them

Cash felt safe during the selloff, but it carries its own opportunity cost. If the investments they would have owned rose 15% while their money sat on the sidelines, a $600,000 portfolio would have gained roughly $90,000, before accounting for whatever interest the savings account paid.

Investor.gov's guidance on market volatility emphasizes having a plan and avoiding panic during market swings. It notes that time in the market, rather than trying to time the market, generally leads to long-term investing success. It also recommends creating a diversified investment plan that fits an investor's risk tolerance and goals.

There's a more immediate issue. The FDIC generally insures deposits up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, for each account ownership category.

For a qualifying joint account, each co-owner generally receives up to $250,000 of coverage, meaning a married couple can generally have up to $500,000 of FDIC coverage in a joint account at one insured bank. If all $600,000 sits in one qualifying joint account, up to $100,000 could therefore be uninsured. Other accounts and ownership categories at the same bank can affect the calculation.

Spreading money across multiple insured banks or using different qualifying ownership categories can increase the amount covered while they decide what to do next.

Cash still has a role in their plan. A common approach is to keep several months of expenses in an insured, accessible account as a buffer, so a future downturn doesn't force them to sell investments to cover a surprise bill.