Husband, 38, Wants Wife To Use Her $1.1 Million Settlement To Pay Off Their Mortgage — ‘That's Not Our Money. It’s Mine.’

Benzinga and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below.

A seven-figure check can solve a lot of problems. It can also create a brand-new one when two spouses disagree about whose problems it should solve.

A 38-year-old woman received a $1.1 million settlement after a car accident and immediately faced a question she hadn't expected to become a marital dispute: Should the money be used to wipe out the mortgage on the couple's home?

Her husband thought the answer was obvious.

The Mortgage Suddenly Looks Very Different

The couple had been married for several years and had about $280,000 remaining on their mortgage. They both worked, had no major debt beyond the home loan and had been making the payments without much trouble.

Most Investors Don't Realize Their IRA Can Hold More Than Stocks And Mutual Funds. Learn More.

The money came from a legal claim stemming from a serious car accident that left the woman with significant injuries and a long recovery. After attorney fees, medical expenses and other costs associated with the case, she was left with roughly $1.1 million to manage.

Her husband suggested using about $280,000 of it to pay off the mortgage .

His argument was straightforward: The house belonged to both of them, they both lived there and eliminating the monthly payment would give the family more financial freedom.

"That's not our money. It's mine," she told him.

The settlement wasn't a bonus from work or an unexpected inheritance. It was compensation tied to something that had happened specifically to her.

She wanted to invest most of the money, keep a portion accessible for future needs and make sure the settlement didn't simply disappear into a house they were already paying for.

Her husband didn't necessarily see it as taking her money. He saw paying off their mortgage as using a windfall to strengthen the household they shared.

That's where the disagreement gets interesting.

Trending: AI Needs More Power Than The Grid Can Easily Provide. This Startup Is Taking A Different Approach To Energy Storage.

Paying Off the House Isn't Automatically the Best Move

There are obvious benefits to eliminating a mortgage.

The couple would immediately remove a major monthly expense, save the interest they would otherwise pay over the remaining life of the loan and own the house free and clear.