Elon Musk is giving away $11 billion in SpaceX stock — and coming out $3.1 billion ahead
Musk need not be thanked for his pretend philanthropy. Instead, he should be thanking us for the massive tax giveaways lining the pockets of the uberwealthy.
Last month, Elon Musk announced on X he wants to give away one share of SpaceX stock to every kid in America — a total of 73 million donated shares worth nearly $11 billion. But it’s hardly altruism. Donating the shares will leave Musk billions of dollars better off.
For one thing, he apparently intends to channel the shares through a tax-exempt charity, likely a charitable foundation or donor advised fund he effectively controls, and distribute them to American kids via Trump Accounts , which would give him a huge tax deduction. At a marginal tax rate of 35 percent, writing off $11 billion in shares would generate tax savings of about $3.8 billion.
Musk has already amassed hundreds of times more than that by avoiding taxes altogether, thanks to our broken tax system. He earned spectacular investment returns not only on his own money, but also on what should have been the public’s money — i.e., money that he would have paid to the government had he been treated like the rest of us and had taxes withheld from his paychecks. Instead, he kept the float, profited from it, and compounded the profits into the stratosphere over time. In fact, 94 percent of Musk’s total wealth is attributable to not paying taxes.
Under a fair tax system, Musk would have had to account for those profits on unrealized gains and pay them back to the government whenever he disposed of his shares. If the $11 billion worth of stock he plans to give away were held to that standard, he would owe the government 94 percent of it, or $10.3 billion.
But that’s not the system we have. Current tax rules not only allow him to avoid paying that $10.3 billion, they also provide him a charitable deduction on his SpaceX “gift,” worth $3.8 billion, for a combined benefit to Musk of about $14.1 billion — $3.1 billion mor e than the value of the shares he is giving away.
Musk need not be thanked for his pretend philanthropy. Instead, he should be thanking us for the massive tax giveaways lining the pockets of the uberwealthy, which the rest of us unwittingly underwrite.
We are the ones who must pay the taxes that Musk and his ilk are exempt from, even the 73 million kids who are supposed to be the beneficiaries of Musk’s largesse. Yes, thanks to the Trump Accounts created by the 2025 One Big Beautiful Bill Act and new IRS rules, those kids can get a SpaceX share in their individual Trump Account, which appreciate tax-free. But when they withdraw the money after they turn 18, unlike Musk, they still have to pay taxes on any gains.
The big beautiful bill required the accounts to be invested in low-cost, diversified index funds, so that children aren’t exposed to undue investment risk from a particular stock. The SpaceX stock donation arrangement flagrantly violates that rule. It requires Trump Accounts to hold the donated shares for at least five years, during which time the nation’s children will be subject to the vicissitudes of SpaceX, and assuming Musk’s proposed merger goes through, of Tesla.
The five-year requirement is for Musk’s personal benefit: it prevents a short-term sell-off of SpaceX shares that could depress their trading price and lower the value of Musk’s continuing stake.
Could SpaceX shares tank, even when 73 million Americans are required to hold onto them for five years? You bet. Would that affect the value of Musk’s tax deduction from the donation? No way.
You may ask, how is this even legal? It shouldn’t be, but the fix is in. On Sept. 30, an obliging IRS issued regulations tailored to allowing Musk to move forward with the stock donation without fear of effective legal challenge.
The scheme projects the misleading impression that Musk and Donald Trump are acting as public benefactors, when in fact they are picking the public’s pockets. Consider this alongside the record-breaking $400+ million Musk donated for political ads and campaigns in this midterm election cycle (up from $290 million in 2024) , and it becomes clear he is leveraging his vast wealth — 94 percent of which is a result of our unfair tax system — to further shape our society for his own benefit.
Stephen Land is a retired tax attorney and co-host of the Fair Share podcast . Bob Lord is senior vice president for tax policy at Patriotic Millionaires, an associate fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies, and writes on tax policy on Substack .
Topics in this story
Gathered from external sources. Rights to this text belong to whoever originally published it.